Sleeping Without a Brain: How Jellyfish Reveal the True Purpose of Sleep

1. Introduction: The Universal Paradox of Sleep

In the grand theatre of biological evolution, few phenomena are as pervasive and yet as perplexing as sleep. It is a behavior that appears to defy the basic mandates of survival. For a significant portion of its life, an animal enters a state of vulnerability, severing its sensory connection to the environment, ceasing to forage for food, and suspending the drive to reproduce. In a Darwinian world governed by the ruthless efficiency of natural selection, such a costly behavior should have been weeded out eons ago. Yet, it persists. From the complex neural networks of primates to the humble fruit fly, and as recent evidence suggests, to the very dawn of the nervous system itself, sleep is omnipresent.¹

For decades, the scientific consensus viewed sleep through a neurocentric lens, framing it as a service provided for the benefit of complex brains. Theories abounded: sleep existed to consolidate memories, to process complex information, or to regulate synaptic weights—the strength of connections between neurons—to prevent saturation and energetic burnout (the Synaptic Homeostasis Hypothesis).² These theories, while robust for mammals and birds, faced a critical stumbling block when applied to the lower rungs of the evolutionary ladder. If sleep is a function of complex cognition, why do simple organisms sleep?

The answer, it seems, lies not in the software of the mind, but in the hardware of the cell. A groundbreaking study published in Nature Communications in early 2026 has fundamentally shifted the paradigm of sleep research. Led by the laboratories of Professor Lior Appelbaum and Professor Oren Levy at Bar-Ilan University, this research delved into the sleep behaviors of two ancient cnidarians: the upside-down jellyfish Cassiopea andromeda and the starlet sea anemone Nematostella vectensis.⁴ By investigating these "brainless" animals, the researchers have uncovered evidence that the original, primordial function of sleep is cellular maintenance—specifically, the repair of DNA damage accumulated in neurons during wakefulness.⁵ This report provides an exhaustive analysis of these findings, exploring the biology of the organisms, the methodology of the study, and the profound implications for our understanding of brain health and evolution.

2. The Cnidarian Context: Life at the Base of the Tree

To understand the origins of sleep, we must look to the organisms that sit at the base of the metazoan tree of life. The phylum Cnidaria, which includes jellyfish, corals, and sea anemones, diverged from the lineage leading to humans (Bilateria) approximately 600 to 700 million years ago. They represent the first animal lineage to develop a nervous system.⁶

Unlike the centralized brains of vertebrates, cnidarians possess a diffuse nerve net—a decentralized mesh of neurons that coordinates movement, feeding, and sensory perception. If these organisms sleep, it implies that sleep is an inherent property of the neuron itself, independent of brain architecture.⁷

2.1 Cassiopea andromeda: The Solar-Powered Jellyfish

The first subject of the study, Cassiopea andromeda, offers a unique window into the relationship between behavior and ecology. Known as the upside-down jellyfish, Cassiopea inhabits the shallow, sunlit waters of tropical mangroves, such as those found in the Red Sea.⁷

• Morphology and Habit: Unlike typical medusae that drift in the open ocean, Cassiopea settles on the sediment with its bell facing down and its oral arms facing up. This orientation is crucial for its survival strategy. The jellyfish hosts symbiotic dinoflagellates (zooxanthellae) within its tissues. These algae require sunlight to photosynthesize, providing nutrients to the host jellyfish in return.⁴

• Activity Profile: To facilitate this symbiosis, Cassiopea engages in a rhythmic pulsing behavior. This pulsing generates a water current that brings fresh seawater to the oral arms, aiding in gas exchange and filtration. The study characterized Cassiopea as a diurnal species—active and pulsing vigorously during the day to maximize photosynthetic potential, and quiescent at night.⁴

2.2 Nematostella vectensis: The Estuarine Burrower

The second model organism, Nematostella vectensis, provides a crucial evolutionary counterpoint. It belongs to the class Anthozoa (sea anemones and corals), a sister group to the class Scyphozoa (jellyfish) within the Cnidaria phylum.

• Ecology: Nematostella is a small, burrowing sea anemone found in estuarine environments where salinity and temperature can fluctuate wildly. Crucially for the study design, Nematostella is non-symbiotic in the context of the comparison; it does not rely on internal algae for food but captures prey using its tentacles.⁵

• Activity Profile: In sharp contrast to the jellyfish, the study identified Nematostella as a crepuscular or nocturnal organism. Its peak activity occurs during the dark phases or transitions (dusk/dawn), likely to avoid visual predators or to align with prey availability in its murky habitat. Consequently, it sleeps primarily during the day.⁴

The selection of these two divergent species—one diurnal and symbiotic, the other nocturnal/crepuscular and predatory—allowed the researchers to filter out ecological "noise." If both species, despite their different lifestyles, exhibited the same underlying link between sleep and DNA repair, it would argue strongly for a universal biological mechanism.⁵

3. Methodology: Defining Sleep Without a Brain

How does one determine if a jellyfish is asleep? It cannot close its eyes, for it has none. It produces no brain waves that can be read by an EEG. To solve this problem, the researchers relied on a rigorous behavioral definition of sleep, established in model organisms like zebrafish and fruit flies. This definition relies on three distinct criteria: behavioral quiescence, increased arousal threshold, and homeostatic regulation.⁸

3.1 Tracking Quiescence

The primary indicator of sleep is reversible immobility. For Cassiopea, activity is defined by the pulsing of the bell. The researchers utilized infrared video tracking systems to monitor the animals over continuous 24-hour cycles. By analyzing the pixel changes between frames (a method often used to quantify motion in simple organisms), they could determine the frequency of pulsing.⁴

• Observation: The data revealed distinct periods of quiescence. Cassiopea pulsing rates dropped significantly at night. Nematostella showed reduced expansion and tentacle movement during the day. Importantly, this state was reversible; the animals were not in a coma or dead, as they could resume activity immediately upon stimulation.⁸

3.2 Measuring Arousal Threshold

A key feature of sleep is sensory gating—the mechanism that prevents a sleeping brain (or nerve net) from responding to trivial stimuli. To test this, the researchers applied specific stimuli (such as food or mechanical vibration) to the animals during their quiescent periods.

• Results: The study found that sleeping animals exhibited a delayed response time compared to awake animals. A Cassiopea pulsing in the daylight would react instantly to a food drop; a Cassiopea in the "sleep" state at night required a stronger stimulus or took longer to initiate the feeding response. This "increased arousal threshold" confirmed that the quiescence was indeed a sleep-like physiological state.⁸

3.3 Homeostatic Regulation: The Rebound

The definitive test for sleep is homeostasis. Biological systems strive for balance; if an animal is deprived of sleep, it must build up a "sleep debt" that requires payment in the form of extra sleep later.

• The Deprivation Experiment: To test this, the researchers mechanically disturbed the animals during their normal sleep times (e.g., using water currents to prevent Cassiopea from settling into quiescence).

• The Rebound: When the disturbance was removed, the animals displayed a classic "rebound" effect. They slept longer and more deeply (showing even lower activity levels) than usual. This proved that their sleep was regulated by an internal drive (homeostatic pressure) rather than just being a passive reaction to the absence of light.⁴

4. Sleep Architecture and Divergent Chronotypes

The study's high-resolution behavioral tracking revealed that while the function of sleep is conserved, the timing and regulation of sleep have adapted to the specific ecological needs of each species. This diversity in sleep architecture (chronotypes) mirrors the variation seen in mammals (e.g., nocturnal bats vs. diurnal humans).

4.1 The Night Sleeper: Cassiopea

The jellyfish Cassiopea spends approximately one-third of its day in a sleep-like state, a proportion strikingly similar to humans.⁴

• Pattern: Its primary sleep bout occurs during the night. However, the researchers also documented a "siesta" behavior—short naps taken around midday. This biphasic sleep pattern (major sleep at night, minor sleep at noon) is reminiscent of sleep cultures in certain human societies, though in Cassiopea, it may be driven by metabolic saturation from photosynthesis or UV avoidance.⁴

• Regulation: The study suggests that Cassiopea's sleep is heavily regulated by masking—the direct inhibition of activity by darkness (or promotion by light). However, the presence of homeostatic rebound proves it is not only masking; there is an internal counter functioning alongside the environmental trigger.⁵

4.2 The Day Sleeper: Nematostella

In contrast, Nematostella sleeps primarily during the daylight hours.⁴

• Pattern: Its sleep onset aligns with dawn, and it remains quiescent through the first half of the day.

• Regulation: Nematostella appears to rely more heavily on an internal circadian clock. Even in the absence of light cues, the sea anemone maintains a rhythmic cycle of gene expression and behavior. The study highlights the role of conserved clock genes (likely homologs of Clock and Cycle), which drive the transcriptional feedback loops that time the animal's physiology.⁵

This divergence—one species sleeping at night, the other by day—provided the perfect experimental setup. If both species showed DNA damage accumulation during their respective "wake" phases (regardless of whether that was day or night), it would prove that the damage is a result of neuronal activity, not just a side effect of UV radiation or sunlight.⁹

5. The Cellular Mechanism: DNA Damage and Sleep Pressure

The most significant contribution of the Appelbaum and Levy study is the elucidation of the molecular mechanism driving sleep pressure. The "Synaptic Homeostasis Hypothesis" argues that sleep pressure is the accumulation of synaptic strength. The "Nuclear Maintenance Hypothesis," supported by this new data, argues that sleep pressure is the physical accumulation of DNA damage.¹

5.1 The Cost of Wakefulness

Neurons are electrically excitable cells. The metabolic cost of maintaining resting potentials, firing action potentials, and releasing neurotransmitters is immense. This high metabolic rate generates reactive oxygen species (ROS) and other byproducts that can cause physical breaks in the DNA double helix (Double-Strand Breaks or DSBs).¹

• The Findings: Using molecular markers to visualize DNA damage (likely utilizing antibodies against phosphorylated histone H2AX, a standard marker for DSBs known as Γ-H2AX, as used in their previous zebrafish work), the researchers tracked the state of the neuronal genome over 24 hours.¹²

• Accumulation: They observed a linear increase in DNA damage markers within the neurons during the wake phase. For Cassiopea, damage peaked at the end of the day. For Nematostella, damage peaked at the end of the night. The correlation was clear: wakefulness equals genomic degradation.⁵

5.2 Sleep as the Repair State

Conversely, sleep was identified as the period of genomic restoration.

• Clearance: During the sleep phase, the levels of DNA damage markers dropped significantly. The study showed that the rate of repair was insufficient during wakefulness to keep up with the rate of damage; only during the quiescent sleep state could the repair machinery catch up.⁹

• Mechanism: Why does repair require sleep? It is hypothesized that the nuclear dynamics required for efficient repair (such as increased chromosome mobility to allow repair proteins to locate breaks) are incompatible with the transcriptional demands of active neuronal signaling. The neuron cannot "walk and chew gum" at the same time—it cannot process sensory data and fix its DNA simultaneously.¹⁴

6. Proving Causality: Stress Tests and Mutagens

Correlation does not imply causation. To prove that DNA damage causes sleep (rather than just correlating with wakefulness), the researchers manipulated the system using external stressors.

6.1 The UV Experiment

Ultraviolet (UV) radiation is a known DNA-damaging agent. The researchers exposed the cnidarians to controlled bursts of UV light, inducing DNA damage independent of neuronal activity.

• Result: Following UV exposure, the animals exhibited an immediate and significant increase in sleep duration. They entered a quiescent state to repair the damage caused by the radiation. This occurred even if the animal was fully rested, effectively overriding the circadian clock.⁵

6.2 The Chemical Mutagen Experiment

To further isolate the variable, the researchers used chemical agents (mutagens) that induce DNA breaks, such as Etoposide.

• Result: Similar to the UV experiment, animals treated with DNA-damaging chemicals showed a massive increase in sleep pressure. This "induced sleep" facilitated the repair of the chemically induced lesions.

• Conclusion: These experiments demonstrated a bidirectional relationship. Not only does sleep reduce DNA damage, but DNA damage actively modulates sleep drive. When the "damage counter" in the nucleus hits a certain threshold, it triggers the behavioral output of sleep.⁹

7. Evolutionary Implications: The Origin of Sleep

The presence of this mechanism in basal cnidarians allows us to triangulate the evolutionary origin of sleep. If jellyfish (600+ million years old lineage) and zebrafish (450+ million years old lineage) and humans (200,000 years old) all share this trait, it suggests that the link between sleep and DNA repair is a fundamental property of the animal nervous system.⁶

7.1 The "First" Sleep

The study proposes that sleep evolved as an emergent property of the first neurons. When multicellular life began to coordinate movement through rapid electrical signaling (the first nervous systems), the cells involved faced a new metabolic crisis: their DNA was breaking faster than it could be fixed. Sleep evolved as the solution—a temporal segregation of "function" (wake) and "maintenance" (sleep).¹

7.2 Comparative Genomics

The study bridges the gap between invertebrates and vertebrates. Professor Appelbaum's previous work on zebrafish established that detailed chromosome dynamics (the physical movement of chromatin within the nucleus) are key to this repair process in vertebrates. The new findings in Cassiopea and Nematostella suggest this nuclear dance is an ancient ritual, conserved across half a billion years of evolution.¹⁴ The researchers even alluded to future work on sponges (Porifera), which lack neurons entirely, to see if this sleep-repair cycle predates the nervous system itself.¹⁵

8. Theoretical Synthesis: Nuclear Maintenance vs. Synaptic Homeostasis

The "Nuclear Maintenance Hypothesis" supported by this study does not necessarily negate the "Synaptic Homeostasis Hypothesis" (SHY), but it likely predates it. SHY posits that sleep serves to downscale synapses to save energy and space. This is a problem relevant to complex brains with high plasticity and learning requirements.

• Hierarchy of Needs: The new findings suggest a hierarchy of sleep functions. The basal, non-negotiable function of sleep is DNA repair (survival of the cell). In more complex organisms, sleep was co-opted for additional functions like synaptic scaling, memory consolidation, and metabolite clearance (the glymphatic system).

• The Universal Denominator: While a jellyfish may not need to "consolidate memories" of its day in the way a human does, it absolutely needs to keep its neurons from dying of genomic instability. Thus, DNA repair is the universal denominator of sleep.²

9. Implications for Human Health and Future Research

The leap from jellyfish to humans is vast, but the cellular machinery is remarkably similar. The findings from this study have profound implications for our understanding of human health, particularly in the context of aging and neurodegeneration.

9.1 Neurodegeneration and Sleep

Diseases like Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, and ALS are characterized by the loss of neurons and the accumulation of cellular damage. Epidemiology consistently shows that poor sleep is a risk factor for these conditions. The Appelbaum/Levy study provides a mechanistic explanation: chronic sleep deprivation leads to a chronic accumulation of neuronal DNA damage. Over a lifetime, this un-repaired damage may contribute to the genomic instability that precipitates neuronal death and cognitive decline.¹⁷

9.2 The "Sleep as Antioxidant" Concept

We often think of antioxidants as dietary supplements. However, this research suggests that sleep itself is the ultimate antioxidant for the brain. It is the period during which the oxidative stress of the day is neutralized and the genetic blueprint is restored.

9.3 Future Directions

The researchers point toward investigating even simpler organisms, such as placozoans and sponges, to find the absolute zero-point of sleep evolution. Furthermore, understanding the signaling pathway that communicates "DNA damage" from the nucleus to the neural circuits governing sleep behavior could unlock new classes of sleep drugs—ones that target the need for repair rather than just sedating the brain.¹⁵

10. Conclusion

The research of Aguillon, Harduf, Levy, and Appelbaum is a testament to the power of comparative biology. By studying the simple, rhythmic pulses of the upside-down jellyfish and the quiet burrowing of the starlet sea anemone, they have illuminated a fundamental truth about biological existence. Wakefulness is a state of degradation; sleep is a state of renewal.

This cycle is not a quirk of human psychology or a byproduct of mammalian complexity. It is a primordial law of the nervous system, written into the very DNA of the first animals to sense the world. As we struggle with the sleep-deprived reality of the modern world, the silent, sleeping jellyfish offers a stark warning and a reminder: we sleep not just to rest, but to survive. The integrity of our minds depends on it.

Comparative Sleep Data (Table 1)

Feature	Cassiopea andromeda (Jellyfish)	Nematostella vectensis (Sea Anemone)	Humans (Homo sapiens)
Phylum	Cnidaria (Scyphozoa)	Cnidaria (Anthozoa)	Chordata (Vertebrata)
Nervous System	Diffuse Nerve Net	Diffuse Nerve Net	Centralized Brain (CNS)
Chronotype	Diurnal (Day Active)	Nocturnal/Crepuscular	Diurnal (Day Active)
Sleep Phase	Night + Midday "Siesta"	Day (Dawn onset)	Night
Regulatory Driver	Light Masking + Homeostasis	Circadian Clock + Homeostasis	Circadian Clock + Homeostasis
DNA Damage Peak	End of Day (Wake)	End of Night (Wake)	End of Day (Wake)
Sleep Function	Neuronal DNA Repair	Neuronal DNA Repair	DNA Repair + Synaptic Homeostasis
Rebound Sleep	Present	Present	Present

Works cited

1. Cracking the evolutionary code of sleep, accessed January 8, 2026, https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/1111668

2. Sleep memory processing: the sequential hypothesis - Frontiers, accessed January 8, 2026, https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/systems-neuroscience/articles/10.3389/fnsys.2014.00219/full

3. Sleep is not just for the brain: transcriptional responses to sleep in peripheral tissues - PMC, accessed January 8, 2026, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3701596/

4. Ancient animals reveal sleep's original role in maintaining brain health - News-Medical.Net, accessed January 8, 2026, https://www.news-medical.net/news/20260106/Ancient-animals-reveal-sleepe28099s-original-role-in-maintaining-brain-health.aspx

5. Evolution: Jellyfish and sea anemones sleep like humans (Nature ..., accessed January 8, 2026, https://www.natureasia.com/en/info/press-releases/detail/9197

6. Jellyfish sleep restores DNA and extends sleep when damage rises - CHOSUNBIZ, accessed January 8, 2026, https://biz.chosun.com/en/en-science/2026/01/07/K3KJD2QZQJALHNKXLDCPY7DNLE/

7. The need for sleep can be traced back millions of years - Israeli research, accessed January 8, 2026, https://www.timesofisrael.com/the-need-for-sleep-can-be-traced-back-millions-of-years-israeli-research/

8. The jellyfish Cassiopea exhibits a sleep-like state - PMC - PubMed Central, accessed January 8, 2026, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5653286/

9. Brainless Jellyfish Need Rest Like Humans, and Reveal Sleep’s Evolutionary Purpose, accessed January 8, 2026, https://www.discovermagazine.com/brainless-jellyfish-need-rest-like-humans-and-reveal-sleep-s-evolutionary-purpose-48505

10. Sometimes jellyfish need a little afternoon nap too | Courthouse ..., accessed January 8, 2026, https://www.courthousenews.com/sometimes-jellyfish-need-a-little-afternoon-nap-too/

11. Sensory conflict disrupts circadian rhythms in the sea anemone Nematostella vectensis - PMC - PubMed Central, accessed January 8, 2026, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10188108/

12. Elevated DNA damage without signs of aging in the short-sleeping Mexican cavefish - PMC, accessed January 8, 2026, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12618005/

13. (PDF) Elevated DNA damage without signs of aging in the short-sleeping Mexican cavefish, accessed January 8, 2026, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/397612963_Elevated_DNA_damage_without_signs_of_aging_in_the_short-sleeping_Mexican_cavefish

14. Parp1 promotes sleep, which enhances DNA repair in neurons - ResearchGate, accessed January 8, 2026, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/356366242_Parp1_promotes_sleep_which_enhances_DNA_repair_in_neurons

15. Jellyfish and sea anemones sleep to repair DNA damage - CHOSUNBIZ, accessed January 8, 2026, https://biz.chosun.com/en/en-science/2026/01/07/K3KJD2QZQJALHNKXLDCPY7DNLE/?outputType=amp

16. Upside-Down but Headed in the Right Direction: Review of the Highly Versatile Cassiopea xamachana System - Frontiers, accessed January 8, 2026, https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/ecology-and-evolution/articles/10.3389/fevo.2018.00035/full

17. Cracking the evolutionary code of sleep - Israel National News, accessed January 8, 2026, https://www.israelnationalnews.com/news/420581