Stratigraphy of a Sunken City on the Nile: Thonis-Heracleion

Introduction

In the annals of maritime archaeology, the rediscovery of Thonis-Heracleion stands as a watershed moment, bridging the chasm between mythological obscurity and historical tangibility. For over a millennium, this ancient port city, situated at the mouth of the Canopic branch of the Nile, existed primarily within the fragmented narratives of classical historians and the whispered legends of a city swallowed by the sea. It was the "Atlantis of the Nile," a place where Heracles was said to have first set foot on Egyptian soil and where Paris and Helen sought refuge before the Trojan War. Yet, until the turn of the 21st century, no physical trace of the city had been identified, leading many scholars to question its very existence or to conflate it entirely with neighboring settlements.

The narrative shifted irrevocably in the year 2000, when the European Institute for Underwater Archaeology (IEASM), under the direction of Franck Goddio, located the city submerged beneath the turbid waters of Abu Qir Bay, approximately 6.5 kilometers off the coast of modern Alexandria. The subsequent quarter-century of excavation has revealed not merely a city, but a cosmopolitan metropolis that served as the obligatory port of entry for all maritime traffic into Egypt during the Late Period (664–332 BCE). Thonis-Heracleion was the operational interface between the xenophobic traditions of Pharaonic Egypt and the expansive commercial energy of the Greek world, a zone of contact where trade, religion, and warfare intersected.

As we approach the end of 2025, the significance of Thonis-Heracleion has achieved new prominence. The recent opening of the Grand Egyptian Museum (GEM) in Giza in November 2025 ¹ has brought the city's treasures to a global audience on an unprecedented scale. Simultaneously, the 2024–2025 excavation seasons have yielded discoveries of profound importance: a temple dedicated to the Greek goddess Aphrodite and a military garrison housing the weaponry of Greek mercenaries.³ These findings compel a reassessment of the city's cultural landscape, suggesting a degree of Greco-Egyptian integration that predates the Ptolemaic dynasty.

This report provides an exhaustive analysis of Thonis-Heracleion, synthesizing the latest archaeological data with geological, historical, and economic insights. It explores the city's dual identity as a religious sanctuary and a commercial powerhouse, the catastrophic geological events that led to its submergence, and the technological methodologies that have enabled its resurrection. Through a detailed examination of the Decree of Sais, the Temple of Amun-Gereb, and the newly discovered Sanctuary of Aphrodite, we reconstruct the life and death of a city that once held the keys to the wealth of the Pharaohs.

The Historical Geography and Topography of the Canopic Branch

The Gatekeeper of the Nile

To comprehend the strategic primacy of Thonis-Heracleion, one must reconstruct the geography of the ancient Nile Delta, a landscape radically different from the coastline of the 21st century. In antiquity, the Nile bifurcated into seven major branches, of which the Canopic branch was the westernmost and most navigable for deep-draft vessels coming from the Mediterranean. Thonis-Heracleion was situated at the very mouth of this branch, acting as the sentinel and customs checkpoint for the entire riverine system.⁵

The city was not a monolithic landmass but an archipelago. Topographical mapping by the IEASM has revealed a "Venetian" layout, where the city was constructed upon a series of adjoining islands and sandbanks separated by a complex network of channels, basins, and canals. This configuration was not merely aesthetic but functional, designed to manage the immense volume of maritime traffic that characterized the port's daily life. The central island housed the great temple precincts, while the peripheral islands supported residential districts, industrial zones, and the secondary harbor facilities.⁷

The Dual Nomenclature: Thonis and Heracleion

For centuries, the relationship between "Thonis" and "Heracleion" was a subject of academic debate. Egyptian decrees referred to a port called Hone (or Thonis), meaning "The Lake" or "The Marsh," a name that reflected its topographical reality as a liminal zone between the river and the sea. Conversely, Greek texts spoke of Heracleion, named after the prominent Temple of Heracles that dominated the city's skyline.

The resolution to this enigma was provided by the site itself. The discovery of the Decree of Sais stela within the underwater ruins confirmed that Thonis and Heracleion were one and the same. The stela explicitly states that it was to be erected in "Thonis-Heracleion," effectively merging the Egyptian administrative designation with the Greek religious appellation.⁷ This dual identity was emblematic of the city's function: to the Egyptians, it was the administrative center of the "Mouth of the Sea"; to the Greeks, it was the first point of contact with the divine and ancient land of the Pharaohs.

The Urban Layout and Infrastructure

The urban planning of Thonis-Heracleion demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of hydraulic engineering. The city was organized around a grand canal that flowed from the north to the south, connecting the Mediterranean harbor basins with the inner riverine port. This central artery allowed for the seamless transshipment of goods from the heavy, deep-hulled Greek merchant ships (which were often too deep to navigate the Nile proper) to the shallow-draft Egyptian river barges (baris) that carried cargo inland to cities such as Naukratis, Sais, and Memphis.⁹

The scale of this maritime infrastructure is evidenced by the sheer quantity of nautical equipment recovered from the seabed. To date, the excavation team has documented over 700 anchors, ranging from limestone Egyptian anchors to lead-stock Greek and Roman anchors. This represents the largest collection of ancient anchors ever discovered at a single site, attesting to the density of shipping traffic that the port accommodated over the centuries.⁹

Geological Cataclysm: The Physics of Submergence

The disappearance of Thonis-Heracleion was not the result of a single, sudden event, but rather a complex interplay of long-term geological instability and acute catastrophic triggers. The research conducted by Jean-Daniel Stanley and the IEASM team has provided a detailed forensic reconstruction of the city's demise, centering on the phenomenon of soil liquefaction.¹⁰

Soil Mechanics and Liquefaction

The geological foundation of Thonis-Heracleion was inherently precarious. The city was built upon the Holocene sediments of the Nile Delta, a sequence of deposits characterized by alternating layers of heavy, water-saturated clays and loose sands.

• Clay Mineralogy: The clay fraction of these sediments is dominated by smectite, a mineral group known for its high shrink-swell capacity and plasticity. Unlike the more stable kaolinite or illite found in other regions, smectite clays are prone to significant volume changes and loss of cohesion when subjected to stress or changes in water content.¹²

• The Mechanism of Liquefaction: The primary agent of the city's destruction was soil liquefaction. This phenomenon occurs when saturated, unconsolidated soil loses its strength and stiffness in response to applied stress—such as earthquake shaking—causing it to behave like a liquid. When the pore water pressure within the sandy layers increases, the effective stress drops to zero, and the soil slurry can no longer support the weight of the structures above it.

The Seismic Trigger

The archaeological record, combined with historical seismicity data, points to a series of cataclysmic events that sealed the city's fate. The southern coast of the Mediterranean is tectonically active, influenced by the subduction of the African plate beneath the Eurasian plate along the Hellenic Arc.

• The Mid-Second Century BCE Event: A major seismic event occurred around 140 BCE. This earthquake likely triggered widespread liquefaction across the southeastern basin of the Mediterranean. As the ground liquefied, the massive stone structures of the Temple of Amun-Gereb, built on pockets of clay, lost their foundation support and slid—often largely intact—into the fluid mud. This explains the "frozen in time" nature of the ruins, where walls and columns are found toppled in alignment.⁶

• The 8th Century AD Collapse: While the Ptolemaic era saw significant damage, the final blow appears to have come in the 8th century AD. A massive earthquake, potentially accompanied by a tsunami, caused the remaining islands to succumb to the sea. The liquefaction of the underlying sediment caused the land surface to drop by several meters almost instantaneously, submerging the city permanently.

Isostatic Subsidence and Sea Level Rise

In addition to these acute events, the city was subject to the relentless process of isostatic subsidence. The immense weight of the sediment deposited by the Nile caused the crust to slowly sink. Combined with the eustatic rise in sea levels following the end of the last Ice Age, this created a scenario where the city was fighting a losing battle against the encroaching water. The "hard clay" that divers excavate today is the re-consolidated remnant of the liquefied soil that once swallowed the city.⁸

The 2024–2025 Excavation Season: New Revelations

The archaeological campaigns of 2024 and 2025 have been among the most prolific in the history of the site, focusing on the southern canal area. These excavations have fundamentally altered our understanding of the cultural and military dynamics of the city, revealing a segregated yet integrated Greek presence.

The Temple of Aphrodite

The most significant discovery of the recent season is the identification of a temple dedicated to Aphrodite. Located in the southern sector of the city, this sanctuary dates to the 5th century BCE, a period when Egypt was under Persian rule but maintained strong ties with the Greek world.³

Artifactual Evidence and Iconography

The identification of the temple was made possible by the recovery of a specific assemblage of artifacts found in situ beneath meters of clay:

• Bronze Idols: Numerous bronze figurines depicting Aphrodite were unearthed. These idols reflect a Hellenistic artistic tradition but were found in a context that suggests local adaptation.

• Ceramic Imports: The stratum associated with the temple yielded a high concentration of imported Greek ceramics, including attic black-figure and red-figure pottery. These vessels, dating to the 5th and 4th centuries BCE, indicate a continuous stream of devotion and trade.¹⁶

• The Bronze Duck Pourer: One of the most exquisite finds was a delicate bronze vessel in the shape of a duck. In Greek mythology, waterfowl such as ducks and geese were sacred to Aphrodite. The discovery of this ritual pourer serves as a definitive iconographic link to the goddess.¹⁶

Religious Syncretism

The presence of a temple to Aphrodite within the sacred precinct of Thonis-Heracleion is a testament to the religious tolerance of the Late Period. It is likely that Aphrodite was syncretized with the Egyptian goddess Isis, particularly in her aspect as Isis-Euploia, the protector of sailors. This syncretism allowed the Greek inhabitants to worship their ancestral deity within a framework that was acceptable to the Egyptian priesthood, facilitating a spiritual cohesion in a multi-ethnic city.

The Greek Garrison and Mercenary Activity

Adjacent to the sacred space of Aphrodite, the excavation team uncovered evidence of a more martial nature: a stockpile of Greek military equipment.

• Hoplite Weaponry: The cache includes bronze helmets (of the Corinthian and Chalcidian types), swords (xiphos), and spearheads. These are the standard armaments of the Greek hoplite, the heavy infantry that dominated Mediterranean warfare in the Classical period.⁴

• The Role of Mercenaries: Historical records confirm that the Saite pharaohs (26th Dynasty) relied heavily on Ionian and Carian mercenaries to defend Egypt's borders against Assyrian, Babylonian, and Persian aggression. The location of this weaponry—in close proximity to the harbor and the temple—suggests the presence of a permanent mercenary garrison. These soldiers were likely stationed at Thonis-Heracleion to secure the strategic entrance to the Nile and to police the lucrative trade that passed through the port.

• A "Sanctuary of War": The proximity of the garrison to the Temple of Aphrodite is not coincidental. In many Greek contexts, Aphrodite had a martial aspect (Aphrodite Areia), and soldiers would often pay homage to her. The discovery of weapons mixed with votive offerings paints a vivid picture of a garrison community that integrated its martial duties with its religious observances.³

The Religious Heart: The Temple of Amun-Gereb

While the Greek sanctuaries provide insight into the immigrant experience, the spiritual axis of Thonis-Heracleion was undoubtedly the Great Temple of Amun-Gereb. This massive complex was the site of dynastic rites that were essential for the legitimacy of the Pharaoh.

The Mysteries of Osiris

Thonis-Heracleion played a central role in the Mysteries of Osiris, one of the most important religious festivals in the Egyptian calendar. Celebrated during the month of Khoiak, this festival involved a ritual re-enactment of the death and resurrection of Osiris, a cycle intimately linked to the fertility of the land and the annual Nile flood.

• The Nautical Procession: A key component of the festival was a nautical procession. The statue of Osiris was transported by a sacred barge from the Temple of Amun-Gereb in Thonis-Heracleion to the shrine of Osiris in Canopus, located a few kilometers to the west. This ritual journey along the canals symbolized the god's passage through the underworld and his triumphant return.²⁰

• Archaeological Confirmation: The excavation of the canal connecting Thonis and Canopus has provided physical evidence of this "Sacred Way." The recovery of ritual barges and votive offerings along the canal bed confirms the descriptions given by ancient authors and depicted in temple reliefs.

The Treasury and the Djed Pillar

Recent excavations in the vicinity of the Temple of Amun have unearthed the "treasury," a repository where the wealth of the temple was stored.

• Precious Metals: The finds include gold jewelry, such as earrings and pendants, and rare silver ritual dishes. In ancient Egypt, silver was often more valuable than gold due to its scarcity and the fact that it had to be imported, likely from the mines of Laurion in Attica or from Asia Minor.¹⁶

• The Djed Pillar: Among the most symbolic finds is a Djed pillar made of lapis lazuli. The Djed is a hieroglyphic symbol representing stability and is associated with the backbone of Osiris. The use of lapis lazuli, a semi-precious stone imported from Afghanistan, underscores the incredible reach of the trade networks that fed the temple's treasury.²⁰

Economic Powerhouse: The Decree of Sais

The economic rationale for the existence of Thonis-Heracleion is codified in one of the most important epigraphic discoveries of the 21st century: the Decree of Sais.

The Stela of Thonis-Heracleion

Discovered by Franck Goddio, this 2-meter-high stela made of black granite is a near-perfect duplicate of a stela found in Naukratis in 1899. Erected by Pharaoh Nectanebo I (380–362 BCE), the decree outlines the taxation policies of the state regarding maritime trade.³

The 10% Customs Duty

The text of the decree is explicit: it mandates that 10% of the customs duties collected on all goods imported from the "Sea of the Greeks" into Thonis-Heracleion must be donated to the Temple of Neith in the city of Sais.

• Taxable Goods: The decree specifically mentions taxes on timber, gold, silver, and processed Greek goods. Timber was a critical strategic resource for Egypt, which lacked forests suitable for shipbuilding. The tax on silver reflects the metal's role as a proto-currency in the Mediterranean trade.

• The "Naukratis System": The stela clarifies the economic relationship between Thonis-Heracleion and Naukratis. Thonis-Heracleion served as the maritime checkpoint and customs house, where goods were assessed and taxed. Naukratis, located further inland, served as the mercantile hub where the actual trading and distribution took place. This two-tiered system allowed the Egyptian state to tightly control and monetize the influx of foreign goods while segregating the foreign traders from the general population.²³

Maritime Archaeology: The Myth of the Baris

One of the most technically significant contributions of the Thonis-Heracleion excavation is the confirmation of a specific type of Egyptian vessel described by Herodotus: the baris.

Herodotus Vindicate

In his Histories (Book 2.96), Herodotus provided a detailed description of Egyptian cargo boats. He noted that they were built of acacia wood, had long internal ribs, and—crucially—lacked the mortise-and-tenon joints that were standard in Greek shipbuilding. For centuries, naval historians questioned the accuracy of this account, as no such vessel had ever been found.

Ship 17

The discovery of "Ship 17" in the sunken city provided the long-awaited physical proof.

• Construction: The hull of Ship 17 matches Herodotus's description with remarkable fidelity. It features thick planks held together by long tenons that are not pegged, allowing the hull to flex. The internal structure is reinforced by massive, crescent-shaped ribs that provide the necessary rigidity for carrying heavy loads of stone or grain.²¹

• Significance: This discovery not only validates Herodotus as an observer of technology but also provides unique insights into the indigenous shipbuilding traditions of the Nile. The baris was a workhorse of the river, perfectly adapted to the shallow, shifting sandbanks of the Delta.

The Ship Graveyard

To date, the IEASM has documented over 60 shipwrecks within the port limits of Thonis-Heracleion. This concentration of wrecks—spanning the 6th to the 2nd centuries BCE—constitutes one of the largest ship graveyards in the ancient world. Many of these vessels appear to have been deliberately scuttled to block channels or reinforce port infrastructure, while others, like the baris, may have sunk during the catastrophic liquefaction events.⁹

Methodology of Recovery: The Systems Approach

The excavation of Thonis-Heracleion presents a unique set of challenges. The site is vast (covering over 110 square kilometers), the water is turbid (with visibility often less than 50 centimeters), and the archaeological layers are buried under meters of sediment. To overcome these obstacles, Franck Goddio has developed a "systems approach" that integrates nuclear physics, geophysics, and traditional archaeology.²⁵

Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) Magnetometers

Traditional magnetometers, which measure anomalies in the earth's magnetic field caused by ferrous objects, were insufficient for the subtle signatures of the Delta's geology. Goddio collaborated with the French Atomic Energy Commission (CEA) to adapt Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) technology for underwater use.

• Sensitivity: NMR magnetometers are capable of measuring the absolute value of the earth’s magnetic field with an accuracy of one fifty-millionth of its value. This extreme sensitivity allows the team to detect the minute magnetic signatures of stone walls, kilns, and even localized geological faults buried deep beneath the sediment.

• Magnetic Mapping: By towing these sensors in parallel tracks over the survey area, the team created a comprehensive "magnetic map" of the city. This map revealed the layout of the temples, the course of the ancient canals, and the location of the harbor basins before a single diver entered the water.

Sub-Bottom Profiling and Excavation

• Parametric Sub-Bottom Profilers: These acoustic devices emit sound waves that penetrate the seabed, creating a cross-sectional image of the sediment layers. This allows archaeologists to identify the depth of the cultural layers (often 3 to 5 meters deep) and to distinguish between the soft Holocene clays and the harder, underlying Pleistocene formations.

• Water Dredges: Once a target is identified, divers use water dredges (essentially underwater vacuums) to carefully remove the overburden of clay and sand. This process is delicate, as the artifacts are often fragile and encased in the hard, re-consolidated clay matrix.

The Grand Egyptian Museum: A New Chapter (2025)

As of November 2025, the legacy of Thonis-Heracleion has been secured within the walls of the newly opened Grand Egyptian Museum (GEM). This institution, located on the Giza Plateau, now houses the definitive collection of artifacts from the sunken city, marking a shift in how Egypt presents its underwater heritage.¹

The "Sunken Cities" Collection

The GEM's "Sunken Cities" gallery features 132 select artifacts from the IEASM excavations.

• The Colossus of Hapy: Dominating the atrium is the 5.4-meter-tall statue of Hapy, the god of the Nile flood. Carved from red granite, this colossus is the largest known representation of the deity ever discovered. Its recovery from the sea floor was a feat of engineering, and its presence in the GEM underscores the central role of the Nile flood in the life of Thonis-Heracleion.²

• The Ptolemaic Royal Couple: Standing alongside Hapy are two colossal statues of a Ptolemaic king and queen (likely Ptolemy II Philadelphus and Arsinoe II). These statues, recovered in fragments and painstakingly reassembled, demonstrate the fusion of Greek portraiture with the monumental scale of Pharaonic art.

• Ritual Objects: The gallery also displays the delicate silver ritual dishes, the gold jewelry, and the bronze idols from the Aphrodite temple, providing an intimate counterpoint to the monumental statues.²⁷

The inclusion of these artifacts in the GEM represents a formal acknowledgment of the importance of maritime archaeology in the broader narrative of Egyptian history. It brings the story of the "Atlantis of the Nile" out of the water and into the canon of world heritage.

Conclusion

Thonis-Heracleion was more than a city; it was a machine of empire. It processed the wealth of the Mediterranean, filtered the influx of foreign ideas, and projected the power of the Pharaohs to the edge of the known world. Its destruction by the forces of geology—liquefaction, subsidence, and tsunamis—sealed it in a time capsule, preserving a record of cultural interaction that is unparalleled in the archaeological record.

The discoveries of the 2024–2025 season have added new layers to this narrative. The Temple of Aphrodite and the Greek garrison reveal a city where Greeks were not just transient traders but permanent residents, integrated into the religious and military fabric of the state. The confirmation of the baris ship vindicates ancient scholarship, while the Decree of Sais illuminates the sophisticated economic machinery of the Late Period.

As excavation continues, powered by the technological precision of NMR magnetometry and the support of global institutions, Thonis-Heracleion will undoubtedly yield further secrets. It serves as a potent reminder of the fragility of human endeavor in the face of geological time, and of the enduring power of the sea to both destroy and preserve.

Table 1: Chronological Framework of Thonis-Heracleion

Period	Date Range	Key Events & Developments	Geological Context
Foundation	8th Century BCE	Initial settlement of the site; establishment of the Temple of Amun-Gereb.	Construction on unconsolidated Holocene islands.
Saite Period	664–525 BCE	Expansion of the port; arrival of Greek mercenaries; erection of the Decree of Sais (Nectanebo I).	Gradual isostatic subsidence begins due to sediment load.
Persian Period	525–332 BCE	Continued trade; construction of the Temple of Aphrodite (5th c. BCE).	Port remains active despite political turmoil.
Ptolemaic Period	332–30 BCE	Peak prosperity; colossal statues erected; syncretism of Greek/Egyptian cults.	Mid-2nd c. BCE Earthquake: Major liquefaction event causes collapse of Amun Temple.
Roman Period	30 BCE – 4th c. AD	Decline of the port as Alexandria dominates; site remains inhabited but diminished.	Continued subsidence; Roman occupation layers.
Byzantine/Islamic	4th – 8th c. AD	Final Submersion: Major earthquake/tsunami sequence in 8th c. AD destroys remaining islands.	City completely submerged; forgotten by history.
Modern Era	2000–2025 AD	Rediscovery by IEASM; major excavations; artifacts moved to GEM (2025).	Archaeological recovery using NMR and suction dredging.

Table 2: Key Artifacts Recovered (2000–2025)

Artifact Category	Specific Find	Material	Date	Significance
Epigraphy	Decree of Sais Stela	Black Granite	380 BCE	Confirmed identity of Thonis/Heracleion; detailed 10% tax code.
Statuary	Colossus of Hapy	Red Granite	Ptolemaic	5.4m tall; largest known statue of Nile god; now in GEM.
Religious	Bronze Duck Pourer	Bronze	4th c. BCE	Icon of Aphrodite; confirms Greek temple identity.
Religious	Silver Ritual Dishes	Silver	Ptolemaic	Rare liturgical vessels; high value; indicates temple wealth.
Military	Hoplite Helmets	Bronze	5th c. BCE	Proof of Greek mercenary garrison; Corinthian/Chalcidian types.
Naval	Ship 17 (Baris)	Acacia Wood	5th c. BCE	Confirms Herodotus's description of Egyptian shipbuilding.
Jewelry	Gold Earrings/Pendants	Gold	Ptolemaic	Fine Hellenistic craftsmanship; found in temple treasury.

Table 3: Comparative Analysis of Submerged Cities

Feature	Thonis-Heracleion (Egypt)	Helike (Greece)	Port Royal (Jamaica)
Cause of Submergence	Liquefaction + Subsidence + Tsunami	Liquefaction + Tsunami	Liquefaction + Earthquake
Date of Event	Multiple (2nd c. BCE, 8th c. AD)	373 BCE	1692 AD
Geology	Nile Delta (Smectite Clay/Sand)	River Delta (Silt/Sand)	Sand Spit (Unconsolidated)
Preservation State	Excellent (Anaerobic clay seal)	Buried in inland lagoon silt	Good (Coral overgrowth)
Primary Function	Religious/Trade Hub	Religious Center (Poseidon)	Pirate/Trade Hub
Rediscovery	2000 (Franck Goddio)	2001 (Dora Katsonopoulou)	1950s (Ed Link)

Report by:

Persona: Senior Maritime Archaeologist and Historian

Date: November 28, 2025

Subject: Deep-Dive Analysis of Thonis-Heracleion Excavations and 2025 Discoveries

Works cited

1. Service: Newsletter: Latest News - Franck Goddio, accessed November 28, 2025, https://www.franckgoddio.org/service/newsletter/latest-news/

2. Never-Before-Seen King Tut Treasures Go On View at Grand Egyptian Museum, accessed November 28, 2025, https://news.artnet.com/art-world/grand-egyptian-museum-king-tut-highlights-2706526

3. New Discoveries at Ancient Sunken City of Thonis-Heracleion - Nuttersworld, accessed November 28, 2025, https://nuttersworld.com/mare-nostrum-news/thonis-heracleion/

4. Temple of Greek Goddess Aphrodite Found Underwater at Heracleion, Egypt, accessed November 28, 2025, https://greekreporter.com/2023/12/21/temple-aphrodite-found-underwater-heracleion-egypt/

5. Archaeologists In Egypt Discovered A New Section Of The Ancient Sunken City Of Canopus, accessed November 28, 2025, https://www.splashtravels.com/world-history/discovery-ancient-sunken-city-canopus

6. Ancient Greek military ship found in legendary, submerged Egyptian city - Big Think, accessed November 28, 2025, https://bigthink.com/the-past/thonis-heracleion/

7. Projects: Sunken civilizations: Thonis-Heracleion - Franck Goddio, accessed November 28, 2025, https://www.franckgoddio.org/projects/sunken-civilizations/heracleion/

8. 10 Real-Life Sunken Cities - Mental Floss, accessed November 28, 2025, https://www.mentalfloss.com/science/archaeology/sunken-cities

9. The Decree of Saïs - Research Projects, accessed November 28, 2025, https://projects.arch.ox.ac.uk/files/0OCMA/decree%20of%20sais%20for%20web.pdf

10. Fate of two cities built on sinking ground: slow and fast submergence at Thônis -Heracleion and Canopus, Nile River Delta, Egypt - ResearchGate, accessed November 28, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/386134754_Fate_of_two_cities_built_on_sinking_ground_slow_and_fast_submergence_at_Thonis_-Heracleion_and_Canopus_Nile_River_Delta_Egypt

11. Late Holocene erosion of the Canopic promontory (Nile Delta, Egypt) - ResearchGate, accessed November 28, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/310734645_Late_Holocene_erosion_of_the_Canopic_promontory_Nile_Delta_Egypt

12. Chemistry of illite/smectite and end-member illite | U.S. Geological Survey - USGS.gov, accessed November 28, 2025, https://www.usgs.gov/publications/chemistry-illitesmectite-and-end-member-illite

13. Elemental Compositions of Smectites Reveal Detailed Sediment Provenance Changes during Glacial and Interglacial Periods: The Southern Drake Passage and Bellingshausen Sea, Antarctica - MDPI, accessed November 28, 2025, https://www.mdpi.com/2075-163X/9/5/322

14. Heracleion - Wikipedia, accessed November 28, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heracleion

15. These ancient cities sunk to the ocean floor. Here's how they were rediscovered., accessed November 28, 2025, https://www.nationalgeographic.com/history/article/sunken-underwater-anicent-cities

16. Temple "of Aphrodite" revealed in Thonis Heraklion - Archaeology Wiki, accessed November 28, 2025, https://www.archaeology.wiki/blog/2023/09/22/temple-of-aphrodite-revealed-in-thonis-heraklion/

17. Goddio's Team Discovers Artifacts at Thonis-Heracleion - The Hilti Foundation, accessed November 28, 2025, https://www.hiltifoundation.org/stories/sunken-secrets-new-discoveries-by-goddio

18. Decree of Sais For Web | PDF - Scribd, accessed November 28, 2025, https://www.scribd.com/document/426791380/Decree-of-Sais-for-Web

19. Archaeologists discover the sunken temple of Aphrodite brimming with glittering jewels, accessed November 28, 2025, https://www.good.is/archaeologists-discover-the-sunken-temple-of-aphrodite-brimming-with-glittering-jewels-ex1

20. See the Trove of Ancient Treasures, Including a Shrine to Aphrodite, Just Discovered in an Underwater City Off the Coast of Egypt | Artnet News, accessed November 28, 2025, https://news.artnet.com/art-world/sunken-temple-of-treasures-discovered-off-coast-of-egypt-2369782

21. The History Of Thonis-Heracleion, The Ancient Egyptian City That Vanished Into The Mediterranean Sea - All That's Interesting, accessed November 28, 2025, https://allthatsinteresting.com/thonis-heracleion

22. Treasures of Thonis-Heracleion - The Myth, the Legend and the Reality by John Mirosevich, accessed November 28, 2025, https://visit.museum.wa.gov.au/episodes/conversations/2023-10/Thonis-Heracleion

23. Sunken Cities: British Museum's first major exhibition of underwater archaeology, accessed November 28, 2025, https://coinsweekly.com/sunken-cities-british-museums-first-major-exhibition-of-underwater-archaeology/

24. Ancient military vessel found in Egyptian sunken city - The History Blog, accessed November 28, 2025, http://www.thehistoryblog.com/archives/61836

25. Franck Goddio: System Approach & Technology - Franck Goddio, accessed November 28, 2025, https://www.franckgoddio.org/franck-goddio/system-approach-technology/

26. Colossus of a Ptolemaic King - Grand Egyptian Museum, accessed November 28, 2025, https://gem.eg/en/collection/artefacts/colossus-of-a-ptolemaic-king-1

27. 132 items from our excavations on display this week in the new Grand Egyptian Museum in GIza - The Human Voyage, accessed November 28, 2025, http://www.thehumanvoyage.com/blog/132-items-from-our-excavations-on-display-this-week-in-the-new-grand-egyptian-museum-in-giza

28. Official Opening of the Grand Egyptian Museum - Franck Goddio, accessed November 28, 2025, https://www.franckgoddio.org/service/newsletter/detail/grand-egyptian-museum-opening/