Observational Evidence for Relativistic Frame-Dragging in Black Hole System AT2020afhd

Introduction: The Fluidity of Space

In the classical view of the universe, space is a passive stage upon which the drama of matter and energy unfolds. However, Albert Einstein’s General Theory of Relativity, formulated over a century ago, revolutionized this perspective, describing gravity not as a force, but as the curvature of spacetime itself. Among the most exotic predictions of this theory is the concept of "frame-dragging," or the Lense-Thirring effect. First calculated by Josef Lense and Hans Thirring in 1918, this phenomenon posits that a rotating massive body does not merely spin within space but physically drags the fabric of spacetime along with it, much like a spinning spoon rotates the honey in a jar.¹

While this effect has been measured with high precision in the weak gravitational field of Earth by NASA’s Gravity Probe B, observing it in the extreme environment of a supermassive black hole has remained a "holy grail" for astrophysicists. Such an observation requires a system where the relativistic effects are dominant and the geometry is discernible.

This report details the breakthrough analysis of AT2020afhd, a tidal disruption event (TDE) that has provided the strongest observational evidence to date for Lense-Thirring precession. By monitoring the rhythmic "heartbeat" of X-ray and radio emissions from a destroyed star, an international team of researchers has confirmed that a spinning black hole is indeed twisting the cosmos around it, offering a new method to measure the fundamental properties of these celestial titans.³

The Physics of Stellar Destruction

Tidal Disruption Events (TDEs)

A tidal disruption event occurs when an unlucky star wanders too close to a supermassive black hole. As the star breaches the tidal radius, the differential gravitational force—the difference in pull between the near side and the far side of the star—overcomes the star's own self-gravity. The star is shredded into a stream of debris. Roughly half of this material is ejected into the galaxy, while the remaining half remains bound to the black hole, falling back to form a superheated accretion disk.³

This process is violent and luminous, often outshining the host galaxy. The formation of the accretion disk is chaotic; the stellar debris typically arrives on an orbit that is misaligned with the black hole’s spin axis. It is this misalignment that sets the stage for the Lense-Thirring effect.

The Mechanism of Frame-Dragging

In the vicinity of a spinning black hole, the dragging of spacetime exerts a relativistic torque on the orbiting material. This torque forces the orbital plane of the accretion disk to change its orientation, or precess, around the black hole’s spin axis. If the black hole is generating a relativistic jet—a beam of particles accelerated to near-light speed—this jet is anchored to the inner disk. Therefore, if the disk wobbles due to frame-dragging, the jet should wobble in unison, acting like a lighthouse beam sweeping through space.

Detecting this wobble requires a rare combination of factors: a TDE with a jet, a viewing angle that allows us to see the modulation, and a monitoring campaign long enough to capture multiple cycles of the precession.

The Case of AT2020afhd

Discovery and Resurrection

AT2020afhd was first identified in 2020 by the Zwicky Transient Facility (ZTF) as an optical transient in the nucleus of the galaxy LEDA 145386, located approximately 400 million light-years from Earth. For the first few years, it behaved like a typical TDE, with its brightness fading as the stellar debris was consumed.⁶

However, the system exhibited startling behavior in January 2024, nearly four years after the initial discovery. Optical surveys detected a significant "rebrightening" of the source. This renewed activity served as a trigger for a massive, multi-wavelength observing campaign led by the National Astronomical Observatories of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (NAOC) with support from Cardiff University and other institutions.²

The campaign utilized a suite of instruments to dissect the light from the event:

• X-ray Monitoring: Space-based telescopes, including the Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory, NICER (on the ISS), and XMM-Newton, tracked the high-energy radiation from the hot, inner accretion disk.

• Radio Monitoring: Ground-based arrays, such as the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (VLA) and e-MERLIN, monitored the synchrotron emission from the relativistic jet.

• Optical Follow-up: The Xinglong 2.16-meter and Lijiang 2.4-meter telescopes in China provided continuous optical coverage.³

The 19.6-Day Heartbeat

Analysis of the high-cadence data collected between January and November 2024 revealed a striking pattern. Approximately 215 days after the optical rebrightening, the X-ray emission began to oscillate dramatically. The brightness would rise and fall by a factor of ten, repeating this cycle with a regular period of approximately 19.6 days.⁶

Simultaneously, the radio emission from the jet showed a similar, synchronized variability. The radio signal modulated with the same 19.6-day period, and cross-correlation analysis indicated that the lag between the X-ray and radio signals was effectively zero (or consistent with a phase lock). This synchronization is critical evidence. X-rays originate from the innermost region of the disk (a few hundred kilometers across), while radio waves originate from the jet (potentially spanning light-years). For both to wobble in perfect unison implies a rigid coupling between the disk and the jet.³

The researchers concluded that the entire inner system—the accretion disk and the jet—was undergoing Lense-Thirring precession as a single, solid body. As the black hole twisted the spacetime around it, it forced the misaligned disk to gyrate like a dying spinning top, sweeping its emissions across the line of sight to Earth every 20 days.¹

Table 1: Observational Timeline of AT2020afhd

Phase	Timeframe	Observation	Significance
Initial Discovery	2020	Optical flare detected by ZTF.	Identification of TDE candidate in galaxy LEDA 145386.
Quiescence/Decay	2020 – 2023	Gradual fading of luminosity.	Standard TDE evolution (consumption of stellar debris).
Rebrightening	January 2024	Sudden increase in optical brightness.	Trigger for global multi-wavelength campaign.
UFO Emergence	Day 74 – 215 (Post-2024)	Appearance of Ultrafast Outflows in X-ray spectra.	Evidence of disk wind and metal enrichment.
Precession Phase	Day 215+ (Post-2024)	Onset of 19.6-day QPO in X-ray and Radio.	Direct signature of Lense-Thirring precession.

Ultrafast Outflows: The Breath of the Black Hole

Parallel to the precession discovery, the X-ray spectral analysis revealed another dynamic phenomenon: Ultrafast Outflows (UFOs). These are powerful winds of gas launched from the accretion disk at significant fractions of the speed of light.

The high-cadence monitoring allowed the team to witness the entire lifecycle of these winds for the first time in a TDE history. The outflows were not present immediately; they appeared around 74 days after the rebrightening, strengthened significantly between days 172 and 194, and then disappeared after day 215.⁹

Most remarkably, these winds underwent a dramatic deceleration. The velocity of the outflow dropped from approximately 19 percent of the speed of light (0.19c) to less than 1 percent (0.0097c) in just ten days. This behavior challenges standard models of radiation-driven winds. The researchers found an inverse correlation between the wind's speed and its ionization state, suggesting that the delay and deceleration might be caused by changes in the geometry of the wind (the opening angle) or the enrichment of the gas with heavy metals like iron and oxygen as the stellar debris is processed.⁹

The disappearance of the UFOs coincided roughly with the onset of the strong precession signal, suggesting a transition in the state of the accretion disk—perhaps settling into a configuration that supported the rigid body precession observed in the later months.

Implications for Physics and Astronomy

Measuring Black Hole Spin

One of the most profound applications of this discovery is the ability to measure the spin of a black hole. The rate of Lense-Thirring precession is determined by the mass of the black hole and its spin angular momentum. Since the mass of the black hole in AT2020afhd could be estimated from the properties of its host galaxy (roughly a few million solar masses), the 19.6-day period provided a direct constraint on the spin.⁸

The modeling indicated that the black hole in AT2020afhd is a low-spin object, with a spin parameter roughly 10 to 20 percent of the maximum possible value. This distinguishes it from many other supermassive black holes which are thought to spin near the theoretical limit. This "low spin" requirement validates the Lense-Thirring model, as a rapidly spinning black hole would have induced a much faster precession period, inconsistent with the 20-day signal.⁸

Comparison with Previous Candidates

While other TDEs have shown hints of quasi-periodic oscillations (QPOs), AT2020afhd offers the most compelling case to date.

• Swift J1644+57: Showed a 2.7-day period, but the viewing angle was directly down the jet, complicating the interpretation.

• AT2020ocn: Exhibited X-ray modulations with a 15-day period, but lacked the synchronized radio counterpart seen in AT2020afhd.

The dual detection in X-ray and radio for AT2020afhd confirms that the mechanism is global (affecting the whole system) rather than local (a small flicker in the disk), solidifying the frame-dragging interpretation.⁸

Table 2: Comparison of Precession Candidates

Feature	AT2020afhd	AT2020ocn	Swift J1644+57
Period	19.6 Days	~15 Days	~2.7 Days
Wavelengths	X-ray & Radio (Synchronized)	X-ray Only	X-ray & Radio
Black Hole Spin	Low (~0.1 - 0.2)	Unconstrained	Likely High
Interpretation	Rigid Disk-Jet Precession	LT Precession (Disk)	Jet Precession / Instability

Conclusion

The study of AT2020afhd serves as a powerful validation of Einstein’s vision of gravity. It demonstrates that supermassive black holes are not static objects but dynamic engines that twist the very geometry of the universe. The ability to detect this "spacetime whirlpool" through the rhythmic wobbling of a destroyed star provides astronomers with a new tool to map the demographics of black hole spins, shedding light on how these objects grow and evolve over cosmic time.

As we enter an era of time-domain astronomy, with upcoming surveys like the Vera C. Rubin Observatory's LSST expected to discover thousands of TDEs, the techniques pioneered with AT2020afhd will allow us to probe the extreme physics of the event horizon with unprecedented clarity. The "heartbeat" of AT2020afhd may be the first of many such signals, revealing the hidden dance of matter and spacetime in the deep universe.

Data Sources and Further Reading:

¹

Works cited

1. Star wobble reveals black hole dragging spacetime, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.spacedaily.com/reports/Star_wobble_reveals_black_hole_dragging_spacetime_999.html

2. Einstein's theory comes wrapped up with a bow: astronomers spot star “wobbling” around black hole - Cardiff University, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.cardiff.ac.uk/news/view/2990399-einsteins-theory-comes-wrapped-up-with-a-bow-astronomers-spot-star-wobbling-around-black-hole

3. Astronomers Reveal a Co-Precessing Black Hole Disk-Jet System, accessed January 5, 2026, https://english.nao.cas.cn/newsevents/researchprogress/202512/t20251211_1135921.html

4. Scientists Finally Observe a Black Hole Twisting Spacetime — Just as Einstein Once Predicted, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.greenmatters.com/pn/scientists-finally-observe-a-black-hole-twisting-spacetime-just-as-einstein-once-predicted

5. Astronomers just watched a black hole twist spacetime - ScienceDaily, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2025/12/251218060556.htm

6. Scientists Discover First Clear Observation of Disk-Jet Co-precession in Tidal Disruption Event - Chinese Academy of Sciences, accessed January 5, 2026, https://english.cas.cn/newsroom/research_news/phys/202512/t20251212_1136062.shtml

7. Astronomers discover spacetime drag around a supermassive black hole — as predicted by Einstein - The Brighter Side of News, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.thebrighterside.news/post/astronomers-discover-spacetime-drag-around-a-supermassive-black-hole-as-predicted-by-einstein/

8. Detection of disk-jet coprecession in a tidal disruption event - PMC - PubMed Central, accessed January 5, 2026, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12694040/

9. Delayed Launch of Ultrafast Outflows in the Tidal Disruption Event AT2020afhd - arXiv, accessed January 5, 2026, https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.15482

10. Open-Sourcing the Universe's Code: Disk–Jet Coprecession in a TDE | by Manuel Alfaro, accessed January 5, 2026, https://medium.com/@m.alfaro.007/open-sourcing-the-universes-code-disk-jet-coprecession-in-a-tde-e4e2bdea95e2

11. Propagation of Precessing Jet in Envelope of Tidal Disruption Events - arXiv, accessed January 5, 2026, https://arxiv.org/html/2508.11578v1

12. Einstein's right again: Scientists catch a feasting black hole dragging the very fabric of spacetime | Space, accessed January 5, 2026, https://www.space.com/astronomy/black-holes/einsteins-right-again-scientists-catch-a-feasting-black-hole-dragging-the-very-fabric-of-spacetime