The Impossibility of the Early Universe: Rethinking Black Hole Origins Through JWST

1. Introduction: The Dawn of a New Cosmic Era

The study of the early universe has undergone a seismic shift since the operational commencement of the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST). For decades, the standard model of cosmology, known as Lambda-CDM (Cold Dark Matter), provided a comfortable, hierarchical framework for cosmic evolution. In this narrative, the universe began in a hot, dense state, expanded and cooled, and eventually entered the "Dark Ages"—a period before the first stars ignited, where neutral hydrogen fog dominated the cosmos. Slowly, gravity pulled dark matter into halos, which trapped gas, eventually forming the first population of stars (Population III) and subsequently the first galaxies. In this "bottom-up" paradigm, supermassive black holes—the gravitational titans residing at the hearts of massive galaxies—were assumed to grow gradually over billions of years, formed from the modest "light seeds" left behind by the first supernovae.

However, even before JWST, cracks had appeared in this timeline. Ground-based observations had identified quasars—active galactic nuclei powered by feeding black holes—tipping the scales at billions of solar masses when the universe was less than one billion years old. The existence of such monstrous objects so early in cosmic history presented a significant "timing problem." How could a black hole acquire so much mass in such a limited time, especially given the theoretical speed limits on feeding known as the Eddington limit?

The arrival of JWST has transformed this discrepancy into a much broader new hypothesis. By peering deeper into the infrared universe than ever before, the telescope has unveiled a population of black holes that are not only active but surprisingly massive at epochs as early as 400 to 500 million years after the Big Bang. These are not merely rare statistical outliers; they are a burgeoning population that challenges our fundamental understanding of baryonic physics in the early universe. The data suggests that the early cosmos was not a place of slow, gradual assembly, but a chaotic, violent arena where black holes grew at breakneck speeds, potentially originating from "heavy seeds" formed by the direct collapse of vast gas clouds.

This report provides an exhaustive analysis of these revolutionary findings. It examines the observational evidence from key surveys like CEERS and JADES, dissects the physics of "super-Eddington" accretion that allows these objects to gorge themselves, and explores the mysterious new class of objects known as "Little Red Dots" that defy easy classification. We delve into the specific case studies of galaxies like GN-z11, UHZ1, and the record-breaking GS-z14-1, integrating the latest research to construct a coherent narrative of the first billion years of black hole evolution.

2. The Observational Landscape: JWST’s Infrared Eye

The revolution in high-redshift astrophysics is driven by JWST’s unique ability to observe the universe in near-infrared and mid-infrared wavelengths. As the universe expands, the ultraviolet and visible light emitted by the first stars and accreting black holes is stretched, or "redshifted," into the infrared by the time it reaches Earth.

2.1 The Redshift Frontier

Redshift (denoted as z) is a measure of how much the universe has expanded since the light was emitted. A redshift of 10 corresponds to a time roughly 450 million years after the Big Bang. Prior to JWST, the Hubble Space Telescope pushed the envelope to redshifts of roughly 10 or 11, but it lacked the sensitivity and spectral resolution in the infrared to characterize these objects fully. JWST’s Near-Infrared Camera (NIRCam) and Near-Infrared Spectrograph (NIRSpec) have shattered these limits, routinely identifying candidates at redshifts of 12, 14, and beyond.¹

2.2 Deep Field Surveys

The discoveries detailed in this report stem primarily from several ambitious deep-field surveys:

• CEERS (Cosmic Evolution Early Release Science): Focused on the Extended Groth Strip, this survey provided some of the first spectra of active black holes at redshifts greater than 8, including the pivotal object CEERS 1019.³

• JADES (JWST Advanced Deep Extragalactic Survey): A massive program utilizing hundreds of hours of exposure time to obtain deep spectroscopy. JADES has been instrumental in confirming the distances of the furthest known galaxies, such as GS-z14-1.¹

• UNCOVER and The Cluster Lensing Strategy: Utilizing "cosmic telescopes"—massive galaxy clusters like Abell 2744—astronomers rely on gravitational lensing to magnify background objects. This technique allowed for the detection of UHZ1, a galaxy that would otherwise have been too faint to characterize.⁶

3. The "Little Red Dots": A New Cosmic Enigma

One of the most unexpected and widespread discoveries made by JWST is the identification of a new class of astronomical objects colloquially termed "Little Red Dots" (LRDs). These objects appear in imaging data as compact, red point sources, distinct from the extended, irregular shapes of typical early galaxies. Their prevalence has sparked intense debate regarding their nature: are they the first supermassive black holes shrouded in dust, or a new phase of stellar evolution?

3.1 Morphology and Spectral "V-Shape"

The defining characteristic of LRDs is their peculiar spectral energy distribution (SED). In the rest-frame ultraviolet (observed in the blue filters of JWST), they are faint and blue. However, their brightness rises steeply in the rest-frame optical (observed in the red filters of JWST), creating a distinctive "V-shape" or inflection point in their photometric data.⁸

• Compactness: Analysis of their morphology shows that these objects are extremely compact, often with radii less than 100 parsecs. This compactness rivals that of ultra-compact dwarf galaxies or dense nuclear star clusters in the local universe.¹⁰

• Balmer Features: Spectroscopic follow-up of these dots often reveals broad emission lines, particularly the Balmer series of hydrogen (H-alpha, H-beta). In local astrophysics, broad emission lines are a smoking gun for Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN), caused by gas swirling at high velocities (thousands of kilometers per second) in the deep gravitational potential of a black hole.¹⁰

3.2 The Interpretative Dilemma: AGN vs. Stars

The physical nature of LRDs is currently one of the most contentious topics in the field. The evidence pulls in two directions:

The Dust-Obscured AGN Hypothesis: The presence of broad emission lines and the compact nature of the red light strongly support the idea that LRDs host actively accreting supermassive black holes. The "red" color is attributed to a dense cocoon of dust that obscures the central engine in the ultraviolet but allows longer-wavelength infrared light to escape. The "V-shape" spectrum is modeled as a blue accretion disk (or scattered light) visible through a gap in the dust, combined with the reddened light from the dust torus itself.¹² If this interpretation is correct, it implies that the number density of AGN in the early universe is nearly 100 times higher than previously predicted, suggesting that black hole growth was ubiquitous rather than rare.¹⁴

The Supermassive Star / Stellar Cluster Hypothesis: However, LRDs exhibit a puzzling "X-ray weakness." Standard AGN are powerful emitters of X-rays, yet deep integrations have often failed to detect X-rays from LRDs.¹⁰ This has led some researchers to propose that the light is not coming from a black hole at all, but from an extremely dense population of stars.

• The Balmer Break: Some spectra show a "Balmer break"—a sharp drop in intensity at a specific wavelength (3646 Angstroms) that is characteristic of evolved stellar populations (A-type stars). A strong Balmer break is difficult to produce with a standard AGN power-law spectrum.¹¹

• Supermassive Stars: A more exotic theory posits that LRDs could be the signatures of "supermassive stars" (10,000 to 100,000 solar masses) or "dark stars." These hypothetical objects, powered perhaps by dark matter annihilation or extreme fusion, could mimic the luminosity and color of LRDs before eventually collapsing into black holes.⁸

The Hybrid View: Recent analysis suggests a unified picture where LRDs represent a transitional phase. They may be dense nuclear star clusters undergoing "runaway mergers," where stellar collisions occur so frequently that they create a massive central object—a proto-supermassive black hole—surrounded by a dense, dusty stellar nursery. This explains the stellar signatures (Balmer break) alongside the broad lines (high velocity gas/stellar winds).¹⁷

3.3 Implications for Black Hole Seeding

Whether they are dust-shrouded black holes or the dense clusters destined to create them, LRDs are clearly the "cradles" of supermassive black holes. Their abundance suggests that the conditions for forming massive central objects were common in the early universe, providing a fertile ground for the "heavy seeds" discussed later in this report.¹⁴

4. Case Studies of the Early Giants

To understand the mechanisms of black hole growth, we must examine the specific objects that JWST has characterized. These "monsters of the dawn" serve as the primary evidence for the paradigm shift.

4.1 GN-z11: The Super-Eddington Eater

GN-z11 was originally identified by the Hubble Space Telescope as the most distant galaxy known (at the time). JWST has revealed that it is not just a galaxy, but a host to a vigorous, hungry black hole.

• Properties: Located at redshift 10.6 (400 million years post-Big Bang), GN-z11 hosts a black hole estimated at 1.6 million solar masses.²⁰

• Spectral Signatures: The spectrum reveals high-ionization lines of neon (NeIV) and carbon (CII*), which are difficult to explain with starlight alone and point decisively to an AGN.

• The Nitrogen Anomaly: One of the most striking features is the incredibly high abundance of nitrogen relative to oxygen. This "nitrogen-loud" signature is rare. It suggests that the gas in the galaxy has been processed through the "CNO cycle" (a fusion process in stars) and then rapidly ejected. This could be the result of a "Wolf-Rayet" stellar population or, more likely, the result of runaway stellar collisions in the dense environment around the black hole.²¹

• Growth Rate: Crucially, the black hole appears to be accreting at roughly five times the Eddington limit. This "super-Eddington" feeding is the key to reconciling its high mass with its young age. If it can eat five times faster than the theoretical "speed limit," it can grow from a small seed to a million solar masses in a fraction of the time usually required.²¹

4.2 CEERS 1019: The "Light" Heavyweight

While GN-z11 is an extreme object, CEERS 1019 represents a more typical, yet equally revealing, member of the early black hole population.

• Properties: At redshift 8.7 (570 million years post-Big Bang), this black hole weighs approximately 9 million solar masses.³

• Significance: It is less massive than the billion-solar-mass quasars found at later times, making it a valuable "intermediate" specimen. Its mass and accretion rate suggest it could have formed from a heavy seed or a super-Eddington light seed. It serves as a bridge, connecting the first seeds to the giants seen at redshift 6.³

4.3 UHZ1: The "Smoking Gun" for Heavy Seeds

The galaxy UHZ1 is arguably the most critical data point for proponents of the "Heavy Seed" theory. Discovered using the lensing power of Abell 2744, its nature was confirmed by combining JWST data with a deep X-ray stare by the Chandra X-ray Observatory.

• The Mass Ratio Anomaly: In the local universe, there is a well-established correlation between the mass of a supermassive black hole and the mass of its host galaxy's stars. Typically, the black hole is about 0.1% of the stellar mass. In UHZ1 (redshift 10.1), the black hole mass is estimated to be between 10 and 100 million solar masses—roughly equal to the stellar mass of the entire galaxy.²⁴

• Implications: A 1:1 mass ratio is virtually impossible to achieve if the black hole started as a 10-solar-mass seed and grew alongside the galaxy. It strongly implies that the black hole formed first or dominantly, likely starting life as a massive object (10,000 to 100,000 solar masses) via direct collapse. This object is the closest we have come to seeing a "Direct Collapse Black Hole" (DCBH) in the wild.²⁶

4.4 MoM-z14 and GS-z14-1: The Frontier at Redshift 14

The observational frontier has recently been pushed back to just 300 million years after the Big Bang (redshift ~14) with the discovery of objects like MoM-z14 and GS-z14-1.

• GS-z14-1: This galaxy is unexpectedly large (1,600 light-years across) and luminous. While its light appears to be dominated by young stars rather than an AGN, its existence proves that massive structures could assemble incredibly quickly.¹

• MoM-z14: Identified in the "Mirage or Miracle" survey, this object shows a steep ultraviolet slope and compact morphology. The rapid appearance of such bright sources challenges the timeline of structure formation in Lambda-CDM, suggesting that the conversion of gas into stars (and potentially black holes) was highly efficient in the very first halos.²⁸

Table 1: Key High-Redshift Black Hole Candidates and their Properties

Object Name	Redshift (z)	Approx. Age Post-Big Bang (Myr)	Est. Black Hole Mass (Solar Masses)	Accretion Mode	Key Feature	Source
GN-z11	10.6	~400		Super-Eddington (~5x)	Nitrogen-loud; Vigorously accreting	21
UHZ1	10.1	~470		Eddington-limited	Mass ratio ~1:1 with host; X-ray detected	25
CEERS 1019	8.7	~570		~1.2x Eddington	Intermediate mass; broad H-beta line	3
MoM-z14	14.4	~280	Unknown (Compact)	Unknown	Steep UV slope; record distance	29

5. The Formation Debate: Light vs. Heavy Seeds

The central theoretical battleground illuminated by these discoveries is the origin of the "seeds"—the initial black holes from which supermassive giants grow. JWST has shifted the consensus from a "Light Seed" dominated universe to one where "Heavy Seeds" play a crucial role.

5.1 The Light Seed Scenario (Population III Remnants)

The traditional view holds that the first black holes were the remnants of the first stars, known as Population III stars.

• Mechanism: These stars formed from pristine, metal-free gas. Lacking heavy elements to cool the gas, they were likely very massive (100 to 1,000 solar masses). Upon their death, they would collapse into black holes of roughly 10 to 100 solar masses.²⁶

• The Growth Bottleneck: The problem with light seeds is the exponential growth required to reach supermassive status. To turn a 100-solar-mass seed into a billion-solar-mass quasar by redshift 7, the black hole must feed at the Eddington limit continuously for hundreds of millions of years. This is physically unrealistic because accretion is typically episodic; as a black hole feeds, it emits radiation that pushes the fuel away (feedback), causing it to "starve" itself periodically. The discovery of UHZ1 (100 million solar masses at z=10) makes the light seed model mathematically nearly impossible for such objects without invoking extreme, constant super-Eddington accretion.²⁴

5.2 The Heavy Seed Scenario (Direct Collapse)

The "Heavy Seed" model posits that some black holes bypassed the stellar phase entirely, forming directly from the collapse of massive gas clouds.

• Mechanism: In the early universe, a "halo" of dark matter could trap a massive cloud of atomic hydrogen. For the cloud to collapse into a single massive object rather than fragmenting into thousands of stars, the gas must remain hot (preventing fragmentation). The primary coolant in these clouds is molecular hydrogen (). If  can be destroyed, the cloud stays hot and collapses monolithically.³²

• The Role of Lyman-Werner Radiation: The destruction of  requires a strong flux of ultraviolet photons in the Lyman-Werner band (11.2–13.6 eV). This radiation likely comes from a nearby, star-forming galaxy. This leads to the "synchronized pair" scenario: one galaxy forms stars and irradiates its neighbor; the neighbor, bathed in sterilizing UV light, cannot form stars and instead collapses directly into a black hole of 10,000 to 100,000 solar masses.³³

• Validation: UHZ1 is widely considered the first strong evidence for this pathway. Its high mass at such an early epoch is a natural outcome of starting with a 100,000-solar-mass seed rather than a 100-solar-mass one.²⁵

5.3 Intermediate Pathways: Runaway Collisions

A third pathway is gaining traction: the dense nuclear star cluster model. In the incredibly dense environments of early galaxies (like the LRDs), stars are packed so tightly that they collide and merge before they can evolve. These "runaway collisions" can build up a supermassive star of thousands of solar masses, which then collapses into an intermediate-mass black hole. This scenario combines elements of both: it is stellar in origin but produces a "heavy" seed.¹⁷

6. Physics of the Limit: Super-Eddington Accretion

To explain how even heavy seeds can reach the sizes observed in GN-z11, astrophysicists must invoke accretion rates that violate the classical Eddington limit. The Eddington limit is the point where the outward pressure of radiation matches the inward pull of gravity. Exceeding it was once thought to be impossible for sustained periods, as the radiation would blow the accretion flow apart. However, JWST data suggests that early black holes routinely broke this speed limit.

6.1 Photon Trapping and Slim Disks

The solution to the Eddington limit paradox lies in the geometry of the accretion flow. The classical limit assumes a spherical emission of light. However, in a "Super-Eddington" flow, the accretion rate is so high that the disk puffs up into a donut-like shape, often called a "slim disk".³⁶

• Photon Trapping: In these dense flows, the gas is falling into the black hole faster than the photons it generates can diffuse out. The photons are effectively "trapped" in the flow and dragged into the event horizon. This means the black hole effectively swallows the energy that would otherwise push the gas away.³⁷

• Advection: The energy is transported (advected) inward rather than radiated outward. Consequently, a black hole can consume mass at 10 or 100 times the Eddington rate while only appearing moderately brighter than the limit. This "inefficient" radiation allows for rapid mass growth without the self-limiting feedback loop.³⁶

6.2 Observational Signatures

Super-Eddington accretion has distinct signatures that match JWST observations.

• Outflows: While much material is swallowed, the excess energy drives powerful, fast winds from the surface of the disk. The high-velocity outflows seen in the spectrum of GN-z11 (up to 1,000 km/s) are consistent with these predictions.²¹

• Weak X-rays: Because the inner, hottest part of the disk is puffed up and self-obscured, or because the photons are trapped, super-Eddington sources often appear "X-ray weak" or have softer X-ray spectra. This aligns with the puzzling lack of X-rays in many of the "Little Red Dot" AGN candidates.¹⁰

7. The Cosmological Crisis: Is Lambda-CDM Under Siege?

The cumulative weight of these discoveries—massive galaxies, heavy black holes, and rapid formation timelines—has led to significant tension with the standard Lambda-CDM cosmological model.

7.1 The "Impossible Early Galaxy" Problem

In Lambda-CDM, structure forms hierarchically. The number of massive dark matter halos capable of hosting large galaxies is statistically limited at high redshifts. The discovery of galaxies like GS-z14-1 and black holes like UHZ1 implies that baryons (normal matter) were converting into stars and black holes with near-perfect efficiency in the very first halos available.

• The Boylan-Kolchin Limit: Astrophysicist Michael Boylan-Kolchin demonstrated that the stellar masses implied by early JWST observations would require converting almost 100% of the available baryons in a halo into stars—a feat that is physically implausible given the feedback from supernovae and black holes.⁴⁰

• Timeline Compression: The universe at redshift 14 is only ~290 million years old. To form a galaxy with hundreds of millions of solar masses of stars (GS-z14-1) requires star formation rates that challenge the free-fall time of gas in halos. There is simply "not enough time" in the standard chronology to assemble these structures comfortably.⁴²

7.2 Potential Solutions

While some have called for "New Physics" (e.g., Early Dark Energy or modified primordial power spectra), the consensus is currently moving toward "New Astrophysics."

• Bursty Star Formation: If early star formation occurred in violent bursts, it could temporarily boost the luminosity of galaxies, making them appear more massive than they actually are. This would bring the observations back in line with the halo mass limits.⁴⁰

• Top-Heavy Initial Mass Function (IMF): If the first stars were predominantly massive (which is likely in low-metallicity environments), they would produce much more light per unit of mass than modern stars. This would mean our mass estimates (derived from light) are too high, and the galaxies are actually lighter and fit within Lambda-CDM.³⁵

• Dust-Free Growth: The "Little Red Dots" might represent a phase where black holes grew in heavily obscured, dense environments that we previously missed, implying we have underestimated the total black hole mass density in the early universe, but not necessarily the halo masses.¹⁴

8. Conclusion: A Universe in a Hurry

The James Webb Space Telescope has fundamentally altered our narrative of the early universe. We have moved from a picture of a "Dark Age" slowly lifting to reveal the first dim stars, to a "Cosmic Dawn" that was vibrant, violent, and surprisingly mature.

The evidence from objects like UHZ1 and GN-z11 strongly favors a scenario where supermassive black holes did not start small. They likely began as heavy seeds—massive, direct-collapse objects born from the pristine gas of the first halos. These seeds then underwent episodes of super-Eddington accretion, gorging on gas at rates previously thought impossible, shielded by the physics of photon trapping and slim disks.

The "Little Red Dots" stand as a testament to the complexity of this era—a new population of objects that blurs the line between star cluster and black hole, hinting at the messy, chaotic process of formation. While the tension with the standard Lambda-CDM model is real and palpable, it is driving a renaissance in theoretical astrophysics. We are being forced to rewrite the rules of star formation, feedback, and accretion to accommodate a universe that was in a hurry to build its giants.

As JWST continues its survey, and as future observatories like the Roman Space Telescope and the LISA gravitational wave detector come online, we will likely find the definitive "smoking gun"—perhaps the detection of a gravitational wave from a heavy seed merger. Until then, the infrared sky has spoken: the monsters of the dark were there from the very beginning.

Works cited

1. Webb discovers the earliest known galaxy — for now | Steward Observatory, accessed January 26, 2026, https://astro.arizona.edu/news/webb-discovers-earliest-known-galaxy-now

2. NASA's James Webb Space Telescope Finds Most Distant Known Galaxy, accessed January 26, 2026, https://science.nasa.gov/blogs/webb/2024/05/30/nasas-james-webb-space-telescope-finds-most-distant-known-galaxy/

3. [2303.08918] A CEERS Discovery of an Accreting Supermassive Black Hole 570 Myr after the Big Bang: Identifying a Progenitor of Massive z > 6 Quasars - arXiv, accessed January 26, 2026, https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08918

4. Black hole existed 570 million years after Big Bang (NIRSpec MSA emission spectrum), accessed January 26, 2026, https://esawebb.org/images/CEERS3/

5. Earliest, most distant galaxy discovered with James Webb Space Telescope | Kavli Institute for Cosmology, Cambridge, accessed January 26, 2026, https://www.kicc.cam.ac.uk/news/earliest-most-distant-galaxy-discovered-james-webb-space-telescope

6. Gardens of the Galaxy: Has JWST Confirmed the Existence of Heavy Supermassive Black Hole Seeds? | astrobites, accessed January 26, 2026, https://astrobites.org/2023/08/15/gardens-of-the-galaxy-has-jwst-confirmed-the-existence-of-heavy-supermassive-black-hole-seeds/

7. NASA Telescopes Discover Record-Breaking Black Hole - Chandra X-ray Observatory, accessed January 26, 2026, https://chandra.harvard.edu/press/23_releases/press_110623.html

8. Little red dot (astronomical object) - Wikipedia, accessed January 26, 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_red_dot_(astronomical_object)

9. Little Red Dots at an Inflection Point: Ubiquitous “V-Shaped” Turnover Consistently Occurs at the Balmer Limit - arXiv, accessed January 26, 2026, https://arxiv.org/html/2411.03424v1

10. Unmasking the little red dots: AGN or not? - Astrobites, accessed January 26, 2026, https://astrobites.org/2024/11/23/little-red-dots-agn-or-not/

11. Them's the (Balmer) Breaks - AAS Nova, accessed January 26, 2026, https://aasnova.org/2025/03/12/thems-the-balmer-breaks/

12. Back to basics: Little Red Dots as galaxies and dust-obscured AGNs in a synthetic NIRCam sky simulated with L-GalaxiesBH - arXiv, accessed January 26, 2026, https://arxiv.org/html/2511.10725v1

13. AGN-heated dust revealed in “Little Red Dots” - arXiv, accessed January 26, 2026, https://arxiv.org/html/2509.07100v1

14. [2503.05537] Little Red Dots as the Very First Activity of Black Hole Growth - arXiv, accessed January 26, 2026, https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.05537

15. Unmasking the Little Red Dots: Active Galactic Nuclei or Not? - AAS Nova, accessed January 26, 2026, https://aasnova.org/2025/01/21/unmasking-the-little-red-dots-active-galactic-nuclei-or-not/

16. Mysterious Red Dots in Early Universe Could Be Seeds of Supermassive Stars - Science Alert, accessed January 26, 2026, https://www.sciencealert.com/mysterious-red-dots-in-early-universe-could-be-seeds-of-supermassive-stars

17. TRINITY IV: Predictions for Supermassive Black Holes at z ≳ 7 - arXiv, accessed January 26, 2026, https://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.07210

18. JADES-GS-z14-1: A Compact, Faint Galaxy at z≈14 with Weak Metal Lines from Extremely Deep JWST MIRI, NIRCam, and NIRSpec Observations - arXiv, accessed January 26, 2026, https://arxiv.org/html/2507.22858v2

19. Little Red Dots host Black Hole Stars: A unified family of gas-reddened AGN revealed by JWST/NIRSpec spectroscopy | Request PDF - ResearchGate, accessed January 26, 2026, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/398135053_Little_Red_Dots_host_Black_Hole_Stars_A_unified_family_of_gas-reddened_AGN_revealed_by_JWSTNIRSpec_spectroscopy

20. Oldest Primordial Black Hole found to be Growing Faster than Believed Feasible, accessed January 26, 2026, https://telescope.live/blog/oldest-primordial-black-hole-found-be-growing-faster-believed-feasible

21. A small and vigorous black hole in the early Universe, accessed January 26, 2026, https://researchprofiles.herts.ac.uk/en/publications/a-small-and-vigorous-black-hole-in-the-early-universe/

22. [2305.12492] A small and vigorous black hole in the early Universe - arXiv, accessed January 26, 2026, https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12492

23. Heavy seeds and the first black holes: Insights from the BRAHMA simulations - arXiv, accessed January 26, 2026, https://arxiv.org/html/2510.01322v1

24. Earliest Black Hole Ever Spotted at The Dawn of Time And It's Already Huge - Science Alert, accessed January 26, 2026, https://www.sciencealert.com/earliest-black-hole-ever-spotted-at-the-dawn-of-time-and-its-already-huge

25. Photo Album :: UHZ1 :: November 6, 2023 - Chandra X-ray Observatory, accessed January 26, 2026, https://chandra.harvard.edu/photo/2023/uhz1/

26. [2305.15458] Evidence for heavy seed origin of early supermassive black holes from a z~10 X-ray quasar - arXiv, accessed January 26, 2026, https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15458

27. Yale astronomer leads the way to the oldest known X-ray quasar | Department of Physics, accessed January 26, 2026, https://physics.yale.edu/news/yale-astronomer-leads-way-oldest-known-x-ray-quasar

28. Beyond No Tension: JWST z > 10 Galaxies Push Simulations to the Limit - arXiv, accessed January 26, 2026, https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.07695

29. [2505.11263] A Cosmic Miracle: A Remarkably Luminous Galaxy at $z_{\rm{spec}}=14.44$ Confirmed with JWST - arXiv, accessed January 26, 2026, https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.11263

30. A Cosmic Miracle: A Remarkably Luminous Galaxy at z_spec=14.44 Confirmed with JWST - arXiv, accessed January 26, 2026, https://arxiv.org/html/2505.11263v1

31. accessed January 26, 2026, https://astrobites.org/2024/06/14/massive-bh-se/#:~:text=Think%20of%20gas%20as%20the,and%20grow%20efficiently%20via%20accretion.

32. Direct collapse black hole - Wikipedia, accessed January 26, 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_collapse_black_hole

33. Direct collapse to supermassive black hole seeds: the critical conditions for suppression of H2 cooling - Oxford Academic, accessed January 26, 2026, https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/492/4/4917/5709927

34. New constraints on direct collapse black hole formation in the early Universe | Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society | Oxford Academic, accessed January 26, 2026, https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/459/4/4209/2624061

35. Direct collapse black hole formation from synchronized pairs of atomic cooling halos - arXiv, accessed January 26, 2026, https://arxiv.org/abs/1406.7020

36. Super-Eddington Accretion Mechanism - Emergent Mind, accessed January 26, 2026, https://www.emergentmind.com/topics/super-eddington-accretion-mechanism

37. The whole structure of the super- Eddington accretion flow and outflow( Dissertation_全文 ), accessed January 26, 2026, https://repository.kulib.kyoto-u.ac.jp/dspace/bitstream/2433/263471/1/drigk04687.pdf

38. Super-Eddington Accretion in Quasars - MDPI, accessed January 26, 2026, https://www.mdpi.com/2218-1997/11/2/69

39. Super-eddington accretion Definition - Astrophysics II Key Term - Fiveable, accessed January 26, 2026, https://fiveable.me/key-terms/astrophysics-ii/super-eddington-accretion

40. (PDF) Stress Testing $\Lambda$CDM with High-redshift Galaxy Candidates - ResearchGate, accessed January 26, 2026, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/362429351_Stress_Testing_LambdaCDM_with_High-redshift_Galaxy_Candidates

41. Cosmological Tensions in the JWST Era - CERN Indico, accessed January 26, 2026, https://indico.cern.ch/event/1205071/contributions/5071128/attachments/2525580/4343755/boylan-kolchin_TACOS.pdf

42. JWST early Universe observations and ΛCDM cosmology | Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society | Oxford Academic, accessed January 26, 2026, https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/524/3/3385/7221343

43. Primordial black holes in cosmological simulations - arXiv, accessed January 26, 2026, https://arxiv.org/pdf/2506.11233

44. [2509.05459] The possible accretion discs of GN-z11 at redshift z = 10.6, MoM-z14 at z = 14.44 and other high redshift objects - arXiv, accessed January 26, 2026, https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.05459

45. Webb Detects Most Distant Active Supermassive Black Hole to Date - NASA Science, accessed January 26, 2026, https://science.nasa.gov/missions/webb/webb-detects-most-distant-active-supermassive-black-hole-to-date/

46. Newfound Galaxy Class May Indicate Early Black Hole Growth, Webb Finds - NASA Science, accessed January 26, 2026, https://science.nasa.gov/missions/webb/newfound-galaxy-class-may-indicate-early-black-hole-growth-webb-finds/