Titans of the Tropics: Unearthing Costa Rica’s Ice Age Giants in the Orosi Vally

Abstract

The recent unearthing of a significant Late Pleistocene fossil assemblage in the Orosi Valley of Cartago, Costa Rica, marks a watershed moment in Central American paleontology. Announced in February 2026, this discovery has yielded exceptionally preserved remains of the spiral-tusked gomphothere Cuvieronius and the pan-American giant ground sloth Eremotherium. These specimens, colloquially designated "Pital" and "Tobby," respectively, were recovered from a stratigraphically distinct horizon within a fluvial depositional environment influenced by volcanic sedimentation. Preliminary geochronological assessments place the assemblage between 10,000 and 40,000 years before present (BP), situating it within the critical window of the Late Rancholabrean North American Land Mammal Age. This report provides a comprehensive synthesis of the excavation’s findings, detailing the geological context, taxonomic identification, and taphonomic history of the site. Furthermore, it explores the broader biogeographical implications of these taxa within the Great American Biotic Interchange (GABI), analyzing how the unique ecological filter of the Central American isthmus shaped the terminal Pleistocene megafauna. Through a multidisciplinary lens incorporating geology, comparative anatomy, and paleoecology, we reconstruct the ancient landscape of Cartago, offering new insights into the lives and ultimate extinction of these titans of the tropics.

1. Introduction: The Isthmus as a Biological Crucible

The emergence of the Central American isthmus stands as one of the most transformative geological events in the Cenozoic era, fundamentally altering global ocean currents and terrestrial biodiversity. For millions of years, the Neotropical realm of South America evolved in splendid isolation, fostering a unique bestiary of xenarthrans, notoungulates, and litopterns found nowhere else on Earth.¹ Conversely, the Nearctic realm of North America hosted a fauna derived from Holarctic lineages. The final closure of the Isthmus of Panama, an event generally dated to approximately 2.7 million years ago, precipitated the Great American Biotic Interchange (GABI), a biological collision of unprecedented scale where northern and southern faunas surged across the newly formed land bridge.¹

Costa Rica, positioned at the geographical narrowing of this bridge, served as far more than a passive corridor for these migrations. It acted as a complex ecological filter, a holding pen for diverging lineages, and a center of endemism where distinct montane and lowland ecosystems exerted selective pressures on migrating populations.¹ The fossil record of this region is therefore indispensable for decoding the dynamics of the interchange. However, the preservation of fossils in tropical, volcanic environments is notoriously difficult; acidic soils, rapid organic decay, and vegetative overgrowth frequently obscure the paleontological record. Consequently, high-quality Pleistocene sites in Central America are rare, creating gaps in our understanding of the region's pre-human biodiversity.

The discovery announced in February 2026 by the National Museum of Costa Rica (MNCR) in the Orosi Valley of Cartago helps to fill these gaps with remarkable clarity. The recovery of associated remains of a proboscidean and a giant xenarthran—two emblematic taxa of the GABI—provides a high-resolution snapshot of the Late Pleistocene environment.³ This report aims to move beyond the initial news of the discovery to provide a deep-dive technical analysis of the findings. By integrating the specific details of the "Pital" and "Tobby" specimens with established paleontological theory, we elucidate the ecological roles these animals played and the geological processes that conspired to preserve them for millennia.

2. The Narrative of Discovery in Costa Rica

The history of paleontology is replete with discoveries made not by academics in search of specific strata, but by laypeople engaging with the land. The Cartago find follows this tradition, originating from the sharp observations of individuals working the rich volcanic soils of the Orosi Valley.

2.1 The Initial Encounter: 2024

The sequence of events leading to the major excavation began in 2024 on a private property in the Cartago province.³ Geologist María Sequeira Castro was conducting a routine geological survey of a farm, assessing the terrain for land-use purposes. During her traverse of the property, she encountered skeletal elements eroding from a sediment bank. These were not the typical, weathered remains of domestic cattle or horses often found in agricultural settings; their morphology was robust, their density high, and their dimensions anomalous relative to extant fauna.⁵

Sequeira engaged in a preliminary documentation of the site, photographing the exposed bones with scale bars to accurately convey their size. Her initial assessment led her to suspect a paleontological origin, prompting her to contact the National Museum of Costa Rica. This first discovery was later identified as the remains of a giant ground sloth, specifically the genus Eremotherium.³ This initial find alone would have been significant, establishing the presence of Megatheriidae in the valley, but the site proved to be a multi-taxa locality.

2.2 The Second Discovery: The "Petrified Logs" of 2025

The scope of the site expanded dramatically in December 2025. Esteban Brenes, a worker on the same property, located a second concentration of fossils approximately 700 meters away from the initial sloth discovery.⁵ The taphonomy of this second assemblage was deceptive. The bones were encased in a matrix that had induced a high degree of permineralization, giving them a dark, silicified appearance. To the untrained eye, and even initially to the geological surveyors, these large, cylindrical objects appeared to be petrified tree trunks, a common occurrence in the volcanically active regions of Central America where ancient forests were periodically buried by ash falls.⁵

It was only upon closer inspection by the scientific team that the "wood" revealed its true nature. The concentric growth rings typical of trees were absent; instead, the internal structure showed the cancellous texture of trabecular bone, and the external morphology matched the massive limb bones and dentition of a proboscidean. The team had discovered a mastodon, specifically the gomphothere Cuvieronius, lying in the same geological context as the sloth.⁵

2.3 The Scientific Mobilization

Following the confirmation of the second discovery, the National Museum of Costa Rica (MNCR) mobilized a full-scale rescue excavation. The project was placed under the direction of the Department of Natural History, led in the field by geologist Joanna Méndez Herrera.⁴ Recognizing the complexity of the site, the MNCR assembled a multidisciplinary technical team of 12 professionals, including geologists, archaeologists, and biologists.⁴ This core team was augmented by academic interns from the University of Costa Rica (UCR), fostering the next generation of Costa Rican paleontologists.

The excavation also benefited from high-level advisory support. Dr. Lucas Spencer, a paleontologist associated with the New Mexico Museum of Natural History, provided expertise on North American megafauna affinities, while Dr. Guillermo Alvarado Induni, a distinguished Costa Rican geologist and academic, assisted in interpreting the complex volcaniclastic stratigraphy of the region.⁴

Over the course of 13 distinct excavation campaigns, the team engaged in the delicate task of extracting the fossils from the tenacious sediment. The proximity to a riverbank likely introduced challenges related to the water table and sediment stability, requiring rapid but careful extraction techniques. By February 2026, the team had successfully recovered 49 distinct fossil pieces, securing them for preparation and study at the museum's facilities.⁴

2.4 Naming the Giants

In a move to engage the public and honor the specific character of the specimens, the archaeological team bestowed names upon the two primary individuals. The mastodon was named "Pital," likely a reference to a local toponym or feature. The giant sloth was named "Tobby." According to the Minister of Culture, Jorge Rodríguez, the name "Tobby" was chosen as an analogy to a name held in affection by the lead archaeologist's family, humanizing the scientific process and creating a narrative hook for educational outreach.⁶

3. Geological Context: The Orosi Valley Archive

The geological setting of a fossil discovery is as important as the bones themselves, providing the temporal and environmental framework necessary for interpretation. The Orosi Valley, located in the Cartago province, is a depression carved by the Reventazón River and flanked by the towering edifices of the Central Volcanic Cordillera, specifically the Irazú and Turrialba volcanoes.

3.1 Stratigraphy and Depositional Environment

The fossils were recovered from a subsurface horizon exposed along the riverbank. Geologist María Sequeira Castro's analysis of the site revealed distinct, undisturbed layers of soil and rock, indicating that the fossils were in primary context rather than being re-deposited by modern geological activity.⁵

The stratigraphy of the Orosi Valley is dominated by Quaternary volcaniclastics. The depositional environment appears to be a low-energy fluvial or floodplain setting. The completeness of the Cuvieronius specimen—described as "practically complete" ⁵—suggests that the animal was not transported far after death. In high-energy river systems, skeletons are typically disarticulated, with lighter bones (vertebrae, ribs) washed away and heavy bones (skulls, femurs) remaining as lag deposits. The preservation of ribs, vertebrae, and the skull elements of "Pital" implies a quiet burial, possibly in a backwater slough, an oxbow lake, or a floodplain rapidly inundated by sediment.

3.2 Taphonomy: The Silicification Process

One of the most technically interesting details of the discovery is the description of the mastodon bones having a "silicified texture and appearance," which led to their initial confusion with petrified wood.⁵ This points to a specific diagenetic pathway known as permineralization via silicification.

In volcanic environments like Cartago, the groundwater is often enriched with dissolved silica (), derived from the weathering of volcanic glass (obsidian and ash) in the surrounding tephra deposits. When a carcass is buried in such an environment, this silica-rich water percolates through the porous structure of the bone. As the local chemical conditions change (often due to changes in pH or bacterial activity), the silica precipitates out of the solution, filling the microscopic voids of the bone with opal or chalcedony.

This process results in fossils that are exceptionally dense and durable, resistant to both chemical and physical weathering. This preservation bias is fortuitous for paleontologists, as it allows macrofossils to survive in tropical soils that are typically acidic and destructive to organic calcium phosphate (hydroxyapatite). However, this extensive mineralization can sometimes compromise the preservation of collagen, making radiocarbon dating directly from the bone difficult.

3.3 Chronology: The 10,000 to 40,000 Year Window

Preliminary studies have bracketed the age of the Orosi assemblage to between 10,000 and 40,000 years BP.³ This range places the fossils firmly within the Late Pleistocene epoch.

• The Upper Bound (40,000 BP): This date corresponds roughly to the middle of the last glacial period (Wisconsin glaciation). During this time, global climates were cooler, and sea levels were significantly lower, broadening the coastal plains of the isthmus.

• The Lower Bound (10,000 BP): This date marks the Pleistocene-Holocene transition, a period of profound climatic warming and the extinction event that claimed the majority of the world's megafauna.

The dating methodology currently relies on stratigraphic correlation and the known biochrons of Cuvieronius and Eremotherium. The research team is actively seeking carbonized wood or other organic plant matter in direct association with the bones to perform high-precision Radiocarbon (¹⁴C) dating.⁵ Securing a radiocarbon date is critical; a date near 10,000 BP would place these animals alongside the earliest human inhabitants of Costa Rica (Paleoindians), raising questions about human-megafauna interaction. A date closer to 40,000 BP would provide a baseline for the pre-human ecosystem of the region.

4. The Giant Mastodon: Cuvieronius ("Pital")

The proboscidean identified in Cartago is Cuvieronius, a genus distinct from the more famous Woolly Mammoth (Mammuthus primigenius) or the American Mastodon (Mammut americanum). Cuvieronius is a gomphothere, a family of diverse elephant relatives that arrived in the Americas earlier than the true mammoths and successfully colonized South America.

4.1 Taxonomic Identity and Morphology

"Pital," the specimen from Orosi, has been attributed to the genus Cuvieronius based on diagnostic skeletal features, most notably the tusk morphology. The recovery of a complete tusk measuring 1.60 meters is a significant diagnostic event.⁴

• The Spiral Tusk: Cuvieronius is frequently called the "spiral-tusked gomphothere." Unlike the curved tusks of mammoths or the straight tusks of modern elephants, the upper tusks of Cuvieronius exhibit a distinct spiral twist along their axis. Furthermore, they possess a band of enamel that runs spirally along the tusk, a primitive trait retained from ancestral proboscideans but lost in extant elephants.⁸

• Skeletal Stature: Adult Cuvieronius were robust animals, standing approximately 2.7 to 3.0 meters tall at the shoulder and weighing between 5,000 and 6,000 kilograms (5-6 metric tons).⁸ They were stockier than modern elephants, with shorter skulls and a distinct dental morphology adapted for grinding abrasive vegetation.

4.2 Dietary Ecology and Isotopic Signals

The diet of Cuvieronius in Central America has been the subject of extensive research, primarily using stable isotope analysis of tooth enamel. Carbon isotopes (¹³C) in enamel serve as a proxy for the types of plants consumed during the animal's life.

• C3 vs. C4 Plants: Plants photosynthesize using different pathways. Trees, shrubs, and cool-season grasses use the C3 pathway, resulting in lower ¹³C values. Tropical grasses and sedges use the C4 pathway, resulting in higher values.

• The Costa Rican Signal: Research on Cuvieronius hyodon populations in Costa Rica indicates that they were primarily mixed feeders with a strong preference for C3 vegetation.¹⁰ Unlike the grazing mammoths of the North American steppes, Cuvieronius in Costa Rica browsed on the leaves, twigs, and fruits of the forests and open woodlands. This dietary flexibility allowed them to thrive in the heterogeneous landscapes of the Central American volcanic arcs, ranging from lowland forests to montane ecosystems.

The discovery of "Pital" in the Orosi Valley, an intermontane basin, is consistent with this montane adaptation. The 1.60-meter tusk would have been an effective tool for stripping bark, manipulating branches, or digging for roots and water in the volcanic soil.

5. The Giant Ground Sloth: Eremotherium ("Tobby")

Sharing the landscape with "Pital" was "Tobby," a massive xenarthran identified as Eremotherium. This genus represents the zenith of ground sloth evolution in terms of sheer physical magnitude.

5.1 Taxonomic Identity and Scale

Eremotherium belongs to the family Megatheriidae. While popularly associated with their slower, arboreal cousins, ground sloths like Eremotherium were terrestrial titans. The species most commonly associated with the Late Pleistocene of the region is Eremotherium laurillardi, the Pan-American giant ground sloth.³

• Size Estimates: Eremotherium was one of the largest land mammals of its time, rivaling the gomphotheres in mass. Individuals could reach lengths of 6 meters and weights of 3 to 5 tons.¹³

• Locomotion: One of the most unique aspects of Eremotherium anatomy was its pedolateral locomotion. Due to the massive, curved claws on its feet—used for defense and stripping vegetation—these animals could not walk flat on their soles. Instead, they walked on the outer margins of their feet, a biomechanical arrangement evidenced by the distinct morphology of the femur and foot bones recovered at the Cartago site.⁶

5.2 Functional Anatomy and Behavior

The fossils recovered for "Tobby" include a femur and phalanges (claw bones).⁴ The femur of Eremotherium is a marvel of weight-bearing engineering; it is incredibly wide and flattened anteroposteriorly, providing a massive surface area for the attachment of muscles required to support the animal's weight, particularly during bipedal rearing.

• High Browsing: Eremotherium was capable of rearing up on its hind legs, using its massive, thick tail as a "third leg" to form a tripod. In this posture, it could reach vegetation 4 to 5 meters above the ground, occupying a feeding niche similar to that of a giraffe.¹³

• Dietary Niche: Isotopic and microwear studies suggest Eremotherium was a browser that could also process coarser vegetation.¹⁴ In the Orosi Valley, Tobby would have played the role of a landscape engineer, pruning trees and keeping the forest canopy open, which in turn influenced the composition of the plant community.

6. Biogeographical Implications: The Great American Biotic Interchange (GABI)

The discovery of Cuvieronius and Eremotherium in the same stratigraphic context in Costa Rica provides a textbook illustration of the Great American Biotic Interchange. This event was not a singular moment but a prolonged process of migration that reshaped the biosphere of the Western Hemisphere.

6.1 The Corridor and the Crossroads

Costa Rica sits at the narrowest bottleneck of the GABI corridor. Any animal moving between the continents had to pass through this filter. The Cartago assemblage captures representatives of the two primary migration waves:

• The Northern Wave: Cuvieronius represents the southward migration of Holarctic taxa. Proboscideans entered North America from Eurasia and then pushed south. Cuvieronius was highly successful in this migration, penetrating deep into South America, where it survived until the end of the Pleistocene in the Andes.¹⁶ "Pital" represents a population that inhabited the corridor itself, thriving in the tropical environments that connected the continents.

• The Southern Wave: Eremotherium represents the northward migration of Neotropical taxa. Sloths, armadillos, and anteaters (Xenarthra) are endemic to South America. Eremotherium was one of the most successful northern migrants, establishing ranges that extended into the southern United States.¹⁷ "Tobby" stands as evidence of this northward expansion.

6.2 The Savanna vs. Forest Debate

A central debate in Pleistocene studies of Central America concerns the nature of the "corridor." Did a continuous savanna extend through the isthmus during glacial periods, allowing grazers like mammoths and horses to pass? Or did the region remain largely forested?

The dominance of mixed-feeders and browsers like Cuvieronius and Eremotherium in Costa Rican sites—as opposed to the grazing mammoths found in Mexico and further north—supports the hypothesis that Costa Rica maintained significant forest cover or a mosaic "parkland" environment even during glacial maxima.¹ The Orosi Valley, with its volcanic soils and distinct microclimate, likely supported a lush ecosystem capable of sustaining the massive bio-energetic requirements of these megaherbivores. The absence of true grazers in the preliminary reports from Orosi reinforces the view of the region as a "forest filter" that selectively allowed passage to those animals capable of browsing or mixed feeding.

7. The Science of the Excavation

The recovery of "Pital" and "Tobby" was not merely a matter of digging; it was a complex scientific operation governed by the principles of conservation and stratigraphy.

7.1 Methodology

The excavation was conducted under the strict protocols of the National Museum of Costa Rica. The 12-person team utilized standard paleontological techniques, likely including:

• Grid System: Establishing a spatial grid to map the precise location of every bone fragment, allowing for the digital reconstruction of the death assemblage.

• Stabilization: The use of consolidants (such as Paraloid B-72) in the field to harden fragile bones before removal. This is particularly crucial for fossils like the mastodon tusk, which is prone to shattering once the supporting sediment is removed.

• Jacketting: Large elements like the mastodon femur would have been encased in plaster jackets (burlap and gypsum) to ensure their safe transport from the riverbank to the museum laboratory.

7.2 The Significance of "Completeness"

The report notes that the mastodon specimen is "practically complete".⁵ In the context of tropical paleontology, this is exceptional. High precipitation rates and dense vegetation usually result in high rates of biochemical weathering, reducing skeletons to scattered fragments. A complete skeleton implies a rapid burial event. Potential scenarios for such preservation in the Orosi Valley include:

• Lahar (Volcanic Mudflow): A common hazard in the region, a lahar could have engulfed the animals instantly, preserving them in a silica-rich matrix.

• Flash Flood: A sudden rise in the river level could have drowned and buried the animals in sediment.

• Miring: The animals may have become stuck in deep mud or a swampy area of the floodplain, dying of exhaustion or predation before sinking into the anoxic sediment.

7.3 Data Comparison: Recovered Elements

Fossil Element	Cuvieronius ("Pital")	Eremotherium ("Tobby")	Scientific Value
Tusk (Defensa)	1 Complete (1.60m), 1 Fragment	N/A	Age determination, isotopic diet analysis, species identification.
Femur	Recovered	Recovered	Body mass estimation, biomechanical analysis of locomotion.
Vertebrae	Recovered	Recovered	Spinal column reconstruction, pathology analysis.
Phalanges	Recovered	Recovered	Analysis of claw function, grip, and substrate interaction.
Ribs	Recovered	Recovered	Respiratory volume, potential preservation of stomach contents (rare).

8. The Pleistocene Extinction and Human Interaction

The date range of 10,000 to 40,000 BP places these fossils in the shadow of the Quaternary Extinction Event. By approximately 10,000 years ago, Cuvieronius, Eremotherium, and the vast majority of American megafauna had vanished.

8.1 Causes of Extinction

The cause of this extinction is a subject of intense debate, usually polarized between "Overkill" (human hunting) and climatic change.

• Climate: The end of the Pleistocene brought warmer, wetter conditions to the tropics. The open mosaic habitats preferred by these giants may have been replaced by dense, closed-canopy rainforests, restricting their movement and reducing their food supply.

• Humans: The presence of Paleoindians in Costa Rica is well-documented via Clovis-like fluted points found at other sites (e.g., Finca Guardoria).¹⁹ If the Orosi fossils date to the younger end of the spectrum (c. 10,000 - 12,000 BP), "Pital" and "Tobby" would have shared the valley with humans.

8.2 Taphonomic Evidence of Interaction?

So far, the reports do not mention cut marks, marrow extraction fractures, or lithic tools associated with the bones. However, the completeness of the mastodon suggests it was not butchered, or at least not fully processed, by humans or scavengers. This might point to a natural death (disease, accident, or entrapment) rather than predation. Future microscopic analysis of the bone surfaces will be required to definitively rule out human modification.

9. Conclusion: A New Chapter for Central American Paleontology

The discovery of the Orosi Valley megafauna assemblage is a landmark event that resonates far beyond the borders of Costa Rica. It validates the potential of the Central American isthmus to yield high-quality, datable Pleistocene fossils, challenging the notion that the tropical record is too degraded for detailed study.

The specimens "Pital" and "Tobby" serve as ambassadors from deep time. They offer a tangible connection to a world where the familiar landscapes of Cartago were trodden by giants. For the scientific community, they represent a critical data set for reconstructing the paleoecology of the GABI corridor. For the public, they are a source of wonder and national heritage.

As the National Museum of Costa Rica moves forward with the preparation and exhibition of these fossils, the Orosi discovery stands as a powerful reminder of the dynamism of life on Earth. It underscores the fragility of even the largest organisms in the face of environmental change—a lesson from the Pleistocene that holds profound relevance for the biodiversity of the Anthropocene.

Works cited

1. The Great American Biotic Interchange: Dispersals, Tectonics, Climate, Sea Level and Holding Pens - PMC, accessed February 16, 2026, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2987556/

2. Great American Interchange - Wikipedia, accessed February 16, 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_American_Interchange

3. Costa Rica digs up mastodon, giant sloth bones in major find - Global Nation, accessed February 16, 2026, https://globalnation.inquirer.net/309075/costa-rica-digs-up-mastodon-giant-sloth-bones-in-major-find

4. Fossils of a giant sloth and a mastodon from at least 10000 years ago found in Costa Rica, accessed February 16, 2026, https://deultimominuto.net/en/uncategorized/fossils-of-a-giant-sloth-and-a-mastodon-from-at-least-10000-years-ago-found-in-costa-rica/

5. (FOTOS) Así fue como 3 geólogas encontraron los fósiles del ..., accessed February 16, 2026, https://crhoy.com/nacionales/fotos-asi-fue-como-3-geologas-encontraron-los-fosiles-del-perezoso-gigante-en-cartago/

6. Vea aquí qué nombre le pusieron a los fósiles hallados en Cartago ..., accessed February 16, 2026, https://www.teletica.com/nacional/vea-aqui-que-nombre-le-pusieron-a-los-fosiles-hallados-en-cartago_402395

7. Vea aquí qué nombre le pusieron a los fósiles hallados en Cartago, accessed February 16, 2026, https://www.teletica.com/amp/nacional/vea-aqui-que-nombre-le-pusieron-a-los-fosiles-hallados-en-cartago_402395

8. First Known Cranium of Cuvieronius (Proboscidea: Gomphotheriidae) from North America, accessed February 16, 2026, https://www.mdpi.com/1424-2818/18/2/92

9. (PDF) Fossil Proboscidea from the upper Cenozoic of Central America: taxonomy, evolutionary and paleobiogeographic significance - ResearchGate, accessed February 16, 2026, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/280986074_Fossil_Proboscidea_from_the_upper_Cenozoic_of_Central_America_taxonomy_evolutionary_and_paleobiogeographic_significance

10. César LAURITO | Research profile - ResearchGate, accessed February 16, 2026, https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Cesar-Laurito

11. Feeding habits of the Gomphothere Cuvieronius hyodon in Costa ..., accessed February 16, 2026, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/369100803_Feeding_habits_of_the_Gomphothere_Cuvieronius_hyodon_in_Costa_RicaA_biochemical_approach

12. Possible Coevolution of Vampire Bats (Chiroptera: Phyllostomidae: Desmodus) and Large Xenarthrans (Cingulata, Pilosa) in North America and South America During the Quaternary - MDPI, accessed February 16, 2026, https://www.mdpi.com/2571-550X/9/1/2

13. Eremotherium - Wikipedia, accessed February 16, 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eremotherium

14. A Tale of Two Continents (and a Few Islands): Ecology and Distribution of Late Pleistocene Sloths - MDPI, accessed February 16, 2026, https://www.mdpi.com/2073-445X/12/6/1192

15. Family Megatheriidae. Megatherium americanum (A) and Eremotherium laurillardi (B). - ResearchGate, accessed February 16, 2026, https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Family-Megatheriidae-Megatherium-americanum-A-and-Eremotherium-laurillardi-B_fig2_371392583

16. Full article: Diversity of the fossil gomphotheres from South America - Taylor & Francis, accessed February 16, 2026, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/08912963.2022.2067754

17. THE GREAT AMERICAN BIOTIC INTERCHANGE IN FLORIDA, accessed February 16, 2026, https://flmnhbulletin.com/index.php/flmnh/article/download/flmnh-vol45-no4-pp271-312/vol45-no4/1156

18. (PDF) Diversity of the Pleistocene Gomphotheres (Gomphotheriidae, Proboscidea) from South America - ResearchGate, accessed February 16, 2026, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/284820822_Diversity_of_the_Pleistocene_Gomphotheres_Gomphotheriidae_Proboscidea_from_South_America

19. Mastodons in Nicoya? Yes, and other giants also inhabited the area, accessed February 16, 2026, https://vozdeguanacaste.com/en/mastodons-in-nicoya-yes-and-other-giants-also-inhabited-the-area/